No rating system is perfect: Hansa CEO Praveen Nijhara on India's TRP measurement crisis

Despite having television measurement capabilities, Hansa Research, Nijhara said, is not currently evaluating an entry into the ratings business

e4m by Imran Fazal
Published: Nov 20, 2026 9:17 AM  | 7 min read
Hansa CEO Praveen Nijhara Discusses India's TV Ratings Crisis
  • e4m Twitter
  • India's television ratings crisis has highlighted the need for accurate audience measurement, with broadcasters and advertisers struggling due to the absence of regular television rating points (TRPs) and ongoing debates between traditional panel-based measurement and return path data (RPD).
  • Praveen Nijhara, CEO of Hansa Research Group, emphasizes that no measurement methodology is currently perfect, and the industry must explore how different approaches can meet evolving needs, especially as the ratings blackout affects smaller channels more significantly than established ones.
  • The Ministry of Information and Broadcasting's new TV Ratings Policy 2026 aims to enhance measurement accuracy and transparency by increasing the sample size for ratings and allowing for technology-neutral measurement, but the transition has left the industry without a primary viewership benchmark.
  • While some advertisers may be shifting budgets to digital platforms, Nijhara argues that the decline in television advertising is influenced by multiple factors beyond the lack of ratings, underscoring the importance of establishing a credible measurement framework that serves all stakeholders in the television ecosystem.

India's television ratings crisis has brought the question of measurement accuracy back into focus, with broadcasters, advertisers and media agencies struggling to assess audience consumption in the absence of regular television rating points (TRPs).

As the industry debates the merits of traditional panel-based measurement and return path data (RPD) sourced from distribution platforms, the larger challenge is establishing a credible, representative and dependable measurement framework for a fragmented television market.

Praveen Nijhara, CEO of Hansa Research Group, believes the industry is still evaluating the relative effectiveness of different measurement approaches and that it is too early to establish one as the preferred solution. According to him, each methodology offers distinct capabilities, and the focus should be on understanding how they can best serve the industry's evolving requirements.

"It may be early to say. People have been using the BARC ratings. It could have been very useful to them. At the same time, there was no other form of measurement available. I don't think one can say what is better, what is good or what is not so good. All I can say is that none of them are perfect yet and none of them are completely adequate. We can say there is room for improvement," Nijhara said.

His assessment comes at a critical juncture for India's television measurement ecosystem, where the debate is no longer restricted to the accuracy of audience estimates. It has increasingly become about the commercial implications of measurement, the credibility of viewership data and whether the existing framework adequately captures television consumption across markets, genres and audience segments.

Also Read: News broadcasters flag four-fold gap in TV viewership data, seek RPD-led measurement

GTPL ratings row: MIB action puts DPOs’ RPD-based TV ratings plans under the lens

BARC running out of funds as monthly expenses touch ₹25 crore; Nakul Chopra flags concerns

Uncertainty over BARC continuity threatens wider M&E industry, from advertising to TV jobs

Ratings blackout exposes dependence on a single measurement currency

The ratings blackout has also exposed how dependent the television business has become on a common measurement currency. TRPs are used by broadcasters to demonstrate the performance of channels and programmes, by advertisers to evaluate audience delivery and by media agencies to allocate advertising budgets.

The Ministry of Information and Broadcasting's TV Ratings Policy 2026, notified on March 27, sought to overhaul the measurement ecosystem by encouraging competition, improving transparency and strengthening accountability.

The policy reduced the minimum net-worth requirement for rating agencies from ₹20 crore to ₹5 crore, increased the prescribed sample of metered homes from 50,000 to 80,000, introduced periodic establishment surveys and mandated independent audits. It also provided for technology-neutral measurement, including connected TVs and television channels available on OTT platforms.

The transition to the new regulatory framework has brought changes to the ratings publication process. In July, the ministry asked BARC India to withhold television audience measurement and publication of ratings pending registration under the revised policy. The restriction, initially affecting news ratings, was subsequently extended to non-news genres, leaving the industry without its principal weekly viewership benchmark.

For Nijhara, the immediate concern is that the absence of measurement does not affect all broadcasters equally. Established channels and broadcasters with strong brand recognition may be able to rely on historical performance, advertiser relationships and their existing market position. Smaller channels and challenger brands, however, have a greater need for independently validated numbers to demonstrate their performance.

"It depends on which kind of broadcaster or media company you are. Some who are heavily reliant on these ratings to get advertising revenues would feel the pinch more. Some who would be getting the revenues anyway because they are well-known, big brands or well-viewed brands would be less concerned," he said.

He explained the disparity through the example of a smaller challenger brand competing against a larger, established player. The smaller brand would depend on ratings to demonstrate that it performs well in a particular time band and deserves a greater share of advertising revenue. A larger brand, already perceived to have substantial viewership, may not depend on ratings to the same extent.

However, Nijhara cautioned against interpreting this as an absence of impact on larger broadcasters. The distinction, he said, is between a greater and a lesser impact rather than one group being unaffected.

The longer the ratings blackout continues, the greater the possibility that advertisers and broadcasters will become accustomed to operating without a single measurement system.

"After a while, people get used to the fact that there is no measurement vehicle or measurement system. They evaluate their own way of analysing where they want to advertise, and broadcasters also find their own way of attracting advertisers in the absence of these systems," he said.

RPD versus panel-based measurement

The debate over alternative measurement methodologies has gained momentum with the growing use of return path data. Unlike BARC's conventional panel-based approach, which uses people meters installed in selected households to record viewing behaviour and extrapolates the results to estimate the wider audience, RPD captures viewing information transmitted by connected set-top boxes.

The two approaches, however, measure different aspects of television consumption. Panel-based measurement can capture individual-level viewing and demographic information, while RPD primarily records household or device-level consumption.

The renewed interest in RPD has also led distribution platforms to explore ways to make their subscriber data available for audience measurement. GTPL Hathway, for instance, has begun sharing RPD-based viewership data, while Tata Play has used such data for internal purposes.

Industry discussions have also highlighted the importance of assessing how data from individual operators can contribute to a broader understanding of the country's television audience.

His comments also point to a larger issue: measurement needs to evolve alongside changes in television distribution and consumption. A framework that does not adequately capture the viewing universe, audience composition and differences across markets will struggle to serve the requirements of broadcasters and advertisers.

Despite having television measurement capabilities, Hansa Research is not currently evaluating an entry into the ratings business. Nijhara clarified that the decision was not necessarily driven by the economics of setting up a measurement agency or regulatory hurdles, but by the company's existing business priorities.

“Hansa Research is currently focused on several strategic initiatives, including expanding its international presence through new offices in overseas markets and developing new business verticals and introducing innovative products. Given these ongoing priorities, entering the television ratings business is not an immediate consideration," he said.

The company is expanding its international research operations, with a growing focus on the Middle East, Southeast Asia and the wider Asia-Pacific region. It has also been developing newer research verticals, including customer experience and social research.

Ratings blackout not necessarily driving television ad slowdown

The absence of television ratings has also raised questions about whether advertisers are redirecting budgets towards digital platforms, where audience measurement and campaign reporting remain available.

However, Nijhara does not believe the ratings blackout is necessarily responsible for the decline in television advertising investments or softer ad rates witnessed during the festive period.

He argued that advertisers' decisions are influenced by several factors, including the growing allocation of budgets towards digital platforms, rather than simply the availability of television ratings.

"I don't think it will be because of the lack of ratings or any such thing. There could be other reasons, but I don't think the lack of ratings is a reason why I would not advertise on TV," he said.

He acknowledged that some smaller or more sporadic advertisers might hesitate to invest without reliable audience numbers, but maintained that the absence of ratings alone would not be sufficient to explain a broader slowdown in television advertising.

For the television industry, however, the issue goes beyond short-term advertising allocations. Without a common measurement currency, broadcasters have limited visibility into how their channels are performing against competitors, while advertisers have fewer independent benchmarks to assess the effectiveness of their investments.

The challenge, therefore, is not merely to restore ratings publication but to establish a measurement framework that commands confidence across broadcasters, advertisers, agencies and distribution platforms.

Nijhara's assessment highlights the opportunity for the industry to move beyond the BARC-versus-RPD debate and focus on strengthening television audience measurement. 

By leveraging the strengths of both methodologies, the industry can work towards a more comprehensive, representative and transparent measurement framework that enhances credibility and better reflects viewing behaviour across the country.

Published On: Nov 20, 2026 9:17 AM