Data has a seat in the creative room, but who holds the pen?
As agency groups keep buying their way into consumer data, creative leaders weigh in on where insight should end and instinct must begin
by
Published: Nov 19, 2026 8:55 AM | 9 min read
- The creative process in advertising has evolved from intuition-based briefs to data-driven insights, with tools like identity graphs and AI audience models influencing ideation and strategy.
- Publicis Groupe's acquisition of LiveRamp for $2.17 billion highlights the growing importance of data collaboration in advertising, allowing brands to combine datasets securely without compromising personal data.
- While access to richer consumer data enhances understanding of audience behavior, there is concern that reliance on data may lead to safer, less innovative creative ideas, as similar data interpretations could result in uniformity across campaigns.
- The balance between data-driven insights and creative intuition remains crucial, with industry experts emphasizing that while data can inform decisions, originality and emotional resonance in advertising still depend on human judgment and creativity.
There was a time when a brief began with a client’s gut feel, a planner’s hunch and a creative director’s scribble on the back of a deck. Today, more often than not, the brief arrives with a dashboard attached. Identity graphs, clean rooms and AI-led audience models now sit upstream of the idea, telling creative teams who is watching, what they binge, where they drop off and what makes them tap. Somewhere between the brainstorm and the final deck, a heatmap has quietly acquired voting rights. The uncomfortable question for the creative department is whether all this intelligence makes ideas sharper or simply makes them safer.
That question got louder in May, when Publicis Groupe agreed to acquire LiveRamp, the San Francisco-based data collaboration platform whose clean rooms let brands and publishers combine datasets without handing over raw personal data. The all-cash deal, valued at about $2.17 billion, is expected to close by the end of 2026, subject to regulatory approvals. But LiveRamp is only the latest chapter in a longer story about who owns the audience, and the more interesting plot is unfolding on the creative floor.
Also Read:
Publicis Groupe to acquire LiveRamp
Publicis Groupe completes $2.17 billion LiveRamp acquisition, launches AI growth engine
What Publicis’ LiveRamp deal means for creative advertising
From broad strokes to sharper insights
For creative teams, the most visible change is at the very start of the process. Insights that once leaned on a handful of focus groups and a gut read of culture can now be tested against behaviour at scale, meaning the young urban millennial persona is giving way to clusters defined by what people actually watch, search, buy, and skip. The Indian opportunity makes this hard to ignore.
The Pitch Madison Advertising Report 2026 pegs India’s ad market at ₹1,55,105 crore in 2025 under its expanded definition, with digital already commanding 60%, and projects the market to reach ₹1,74,605 crore in 2026, with digital at around 64%. Every rupee that moves online leaves a trail of signals, and those signals now flow straight back into ideation, versioning and optimisation.
Sini Magon, COO and Global Partner at Grapes Worldwide, a Delhi-headquartered integrated marketing and communications agency with a presence across India, the UK and the UAE, sees that as the real dividend. “Access to richer consumer data is helping creative teams move beyond broad assumptions and understand what actually influences consumer behaviour,” she says.
In practice, it also changes who is in the room. Analysts, data scientists and media teams are being pulled in before the first line of copy is written, and in many agencies a rough idea is now tested against audience segments before it ever reaches the client. That is a long way from the days when the planner’s insight arrived on a single slide.
Rakesh Menon, Chief Creative Experience Officer at Ulka, the Mumbai agency whose legacy dates back to 1961, is firmly on board with the premise. “I’m all for data-led creativity. I think the more we know about our consumers, the better,” he says. His enthusiasm, however, comes with a qualifier most creative leaders will recognise: information is not understanding, and someone still has to make sense of it before it is of any use to a brief.
Holding companies have been stocking up on data for a decade
Agency networks, meanwhile, have decided not to wait for the insight to come to them. Dentsu set the template in 2016 when it bought a majority stake in Merkle, a customer data and experience agency, in a deal that valued the business at about $1.5 billion. Interpublic Group followed in 2018 with a $2.3 billion purchase of Acxiom’s marketing solutions arm, leaving behind the unit that went on to become LiveRamp, and Publicis went bigger still in 2019, paying $4.4 billion for Epsilon, the data and CRM major. WPP took a different route, selling its Kantar stake to Bain Capital in 2019 before picking up the data collaboration platform InfoSum in 2025. Omnicom, which had publicly questioned the privacy implications of rivals owning consumer data, ended up with Acxiom anyway when it completed its merger with Interpublic in November 2025. In agency land, the data aisle has turned into a supermarket, and nobody wants to be seen leaving without a trolley.
What makes the LiveRamp deal different from the earlier buys is the pitch. Publicis calls it data co-creation, where brands and partners pool their datasets in secure environments to build proprietary data assets that can power AI agents, and it will sit alongside Epsilon’s identity capabilities. Publicis has also said LiveRamp will keep operating as a neutral, interoperable platform. For the creative department, the implication is subtler than the balance sheet. When every large network is plugged into a similar set of identity graphs, clean rooms and audience models, the data itself stops being the edge and the advantage shifts to what a team does with it. Menon flags exactly that risk. “But we have to remember that we’re all looking at similar data, and there’s a good chance we’re interpreting it in similar ways too,” he says.
None of this is entirely new, of course, since planners were mining numbers for insight long before data became a boardroom buzzword. Pranoy Kanojia, Vice President and Head of Strategy at Enormous Brands, a Mumbai-headquartered independent agency that works with clients such as Diageo India, believes the debate often gets framed the wrong way. “The first question for me is when in the process and how is data being used,” he says.
He points out that the industry went through the same excitement a decade ago, when data became the catchphrase of every meeting after social media and online commerce platforms arrived. In his view, the craft itself has not changed. “Strategists have always informed sharp creative work by mining insights from various data sources - be it depth interviews, or cultural repositories of the times, or behavioural data from cookie trails, breadcrumbs and app behaviours.”
What the numbers cannot explain
Personalisation is the obvious upside. Brands can now flex a single idea across languages, moments and micro-audiences without rebuilding it from scratch, which in a market as layered as India is no small thing. Magon believes this is where data earns its keep. “Data can certainly help brands understand emerging consumer interests, cultural shifts and audience preferences, making personalisation more meaningful,” she says.
The flip side is work that looks like it was assembled from the same spreadsheet. Campaigns tuned to what has already worked tend to produce more of what has already worked, and every creative director knows the symptom: an ad that would survive a logo swap without anyone noticing. The research on where the real lever lies is fairly blunt. A 2017 study by Nielsen Catalina Solutions, which looked at nearly 500 campaigns, attributed 47% of the sales lift from advertising to creative quality and messaging against just 9% for targeting. The dataset is American and a few years old, but the point travels well: targeting can find the right audience, yet only the idea can make that audience care.
There is also an India-specific wrinkle. The Digital Personal Data Protection Rules were notified in November 2025, and the bulk of the obligations around notice, consent and processing come into force in May 2027, which means the audience intelligence of the near future will have to be consent-led in a way much of the old cookie-era targeting never was. A thinner, more permissioned data layer would arguably raise the premium on ideas that do not depend on knowing everything about the viewer.
The sharpest damage, though, may come at the approval stage rather than the insight stage, when finished work is run through consumer testing and sanded down to whatever scores best. Kanojia is blunt about that risk. “I believe the only place where data-driven decision-making has done any disservice to the creative work is when the creative itself is sliced thin through the prism of consumer testing - enough to take out the magic out of it,” he says, calling it “a surrender of intuition, intuition which is always built on well-informed perspectives.”
That is the gap data cannot close on its own. It can show which thumbnail got the tap, which line held attention and which segment converted, but it is silent on motive. “Numbers can tell us what audiences are responding to, but they cannot always explain why something resonates,” Magon says.
Where instinct still earns its keep
If data is not the villain, AI is the new variable. Audience models and generative tools are trained on what has already worked, which makes them excellent at telling a team that it is on the right track and rather less capable of telling it that the track itself is dull. Menon believes that is precisely why human judgement is gaining value. “AI, for example, can be incredibly convincing. It can validate your thinking, reinforce your assumptions and make you feel like you’re onto something,” he says. The way out, according to him, is having someone in the room willing to question the obvious. “Sometimes you have to challenge what seems logical, because that’s often where original ideas come from.”
Magon draws the same boundary around the technology stack, arguing that originality “continues to rely on human intuition, cultural understanding and the willingness to challenge conventional thinking.” Platforms can surface patterns and open up new possibilities, in her view, but the instinct to take a creative risk cannot be outsourced.
Which brings the story back to the dashboard attached to the brief. A holding company can pay billions for the pipes, and the pipes will keep getting richer, but richer data is available to anyone who can afford the subscription and interpretation is not. Kanojia’s line may well be the one that settles the argument. “Smartness is how one uses the data rather than the data itself.” The dashboard can stay on the desk. It is still the creative team that has to pick up the pen.
Read more news about Internet Advertising India, Marketing News, PR and Corporate Communication News, Digital Media News, Television Media News
For more updates, be socially connected with us onInstagram, LinkedIn, Twitter, Facebook YouTube & Google News
