Hygiene factors are table stakes: Brands toughen agency pitch tests as AOR battle heats up

Marketers are concerned about the gap between the senior leadership showcased during agency pitches and the teams subsequently assigned to manage accounts

e4m by Imran Fazal
Published: Nov 18, 2026 8:46 AM  | 5 min read
Brands Elevate Agency Selection Criteria Amid AOR Competition
  • e4m Twitter

Winning an agency-of-record (AOR) mandate is becoming increasingly demanding for advertising and media agencies, as brands look beyond competitive pitches, media buying strength and creative capabilities to assess how well an agency can contribute to their business objectives.

As agency networks compete aggressively to acquire and retain large media and creative accounts, marketers are placing greater emphasis on talent quality, business understanding, strategic thinking, technology capabilities and long-term client relationships. 

Expectations are also extending beyond pitch presentations, with brands seeking clarity on the teams that will actually manage their accounts and the value they can deliver.

The competition for mandates is reflected in COMvergence's New Business Barometer for India for the first half of 2026. The country recorded 62 media account moves and retentions between January and June, representing estimated media spends of $838 million.

Of these, 46 were local pitches, accounting for $719 million, while 16 global or multi-market pitches represented $119 million. Local pitches accounted for approximately 86% of the total assessed media spend.

Marketers say winning an account increasingly depends on factors beyond the scale of an agency's operations.

Business understanding becomes a key differentiator

For brands, an agency's ability to understand the business, its consumers and category challenges is emerging as a critical consideration.

Pooja Asar, Head of Marketing at Tata Passenger Electric Mobility, said most agencies and networks are at par on basic capabilities, making business understanding a more important differentiator.

"Certain hygiene factors are always expected, and most agencies and networks are at par on those. What truly differentiates an agency is its ability to act as a business partner by understanding my business, my consumers and their concerns," she said.

Asar added that the relationship between client and agency teams plays a significant role in determining the success of a partnership.

"Equally important is the relationship built between the teams on the client and agency sides. That relationship plays a crucial role in shaping how I look at my business and how the partnership evolves over the next three to five years," she said.

Kaushik Vedula, VP, Marketing at Castrol, said an agency's understanding of the organisation's business strategy and its ability to translate that into an effective media plan are central to the selection process.

"The first and most important consideration when evaluating an agency is its ability to understand the organisation's overall business strategy and develop a media plan and strategy aligned with it. If the agency's media capabilities are not aligned with the direction in which the business wants to move, the partnership is unlikely to deliver the desired results," he said.

Vedula also emphasised collaboration across the marketing ecosystem. Media agencies need to work alongside creative agencies and product teams to maximise the impact of marketing initiatives. Technology adoption is another important consideration in ensuring brands derive greater value from their partnerships.

Talent and organisational capabilities matter

Rajesh Jejurikar, Executive Director and CEO (Auto & Farm Sector) at Mahindra & Mahindra, said the quality and capability of people working on an account are among the most important considerations.

"One of the most important criteria we look at is the quality of talent. The people working on our account must have the ability and capability to create an impact for the business. The overall backend capabilities of the organisation and the leverage it has with partners to secure the best deals for us are equally important," he said.

Jejurikar added that innovation, particularly the ability to identify appropriate and optimised solutions, is another key criterion.

Aniruddha Haldar, Senior Vice President, People Mobility (India Two-Wheeler Business) at TVS Motor Company, said the parameters for shortlisting agencies differ from those determining the final selection.

"Shortlisting is largely based on capabilities, organisational size, proven track record, technology stack and the strength of its people," he said.

However, the final decision often comes down to shared values, beliefs and working chemistry.

"When it comes to the final choice of an agency, the most fundamental consideration is whether there is a commonality of values, beliefs and working chemistry," Haldar said, adding that compatible working styles and a common ambition can make the difference between a successful and unsuccessful partnership.

Brands seek transparency beyond the pitch

Another concern among marketers is the gap between the senior leadership showcased during agency pitches and the teams subsequently assigned to manage accounts.

Amit Gheji, Chief Marketing & Strategy Officer at Ashirvad by aliaxis, said agencies should be transparent about the people who will handle the account after winning the mandate.

"One of the biggest concerns is when agencies bring their senior leadership and prominent names into the pitch but subsequently assign relatively junior teams to handle the account. This often leads to attrition and can eventually undermine the partnership. I believe agencies should be transparent about the team that will actually manage the account and allow the client to choose who they want to work with," he said.

Gheji also highlighted the importance of preparation before a pitch. Thorough research into the client and brand enables agencies to customise solutions and demonstrate a deeper understanding of the business.

As brands become more discerning about agency partnerships, winning an AOR mandate increasingly requires more than an impressive pitch. The ability to understand business priorities, provide strategic counsel and deliver consistently through the right talent is becoming central to retaining accounts over the long term.

Published On: Nov 18, 2026 8:46 AM