Scale vs precision? Why digital advertising is no longer an either-or game

India’s digital advertising market is entering a new phase of evolution. No longer confined to its identity as a hyper-targeted, ROI-led performance channel, digital is increasingly being repositioned as a hybrid, full-funnel medium, capable of delivering both mass reach and precision targeting at scale.

Industry leaders say the debate is no longer about digital versus traditional media. Instead, the real shift lies within digital itself: from being viewed primarily as a bottom-funnel conversion engine to becoming a central driver of brand building, scale and measurable growth across categories.

For years, digital in India was largely synonymous with performance. Search, social and programmatic were optimised for measurable conversions, attribution models and lower-funnel impact. Particularly in sectors such as D2C, fintech, edtech and e-commerce, digital was treated as the primary growth lever.

Also Read: Digital projected to command 70% of total ad spends by 2027: dentsu-e4m report 

Digital ad spends climb across sectors in 2025, led by FMCG & eCommerce: dentsu-e4m report

Programmatic ad spends to grow at 19% CAGR by 2027: dentsu-e4m report

However, rising customer acquisition costs, privacy-led signal loss and platform algorithm changes are prompting brands to rethink their approach. The result is not a move away from precision, but an expansion of digital’s mandate - combining reach, storytelling and advanced targeting within a unified strategy.

Neelima Burra, Chief Strategy, Transformation and Marketing Officer at Luminous Power Technologies said, “Whether digital operates as a scale or precision engine depends largely on the brand’s objective. If the goal is conversion, digital becomes a powerful precision medium, enabling us to deliver detailed, specific information that can drive sales.”

Using inverter batteries as an example, she explained that consumers actively seek granular information on capacity, power rating and load compatibility, making precision-led communication critical at the conversion stage. However, during new product launches such as Luminous Edge or when introducing technologies like GTI in solar, digital serves as a scale driver, helping build widespread awareness.

For the brand, therefore, digital operates as a scale engine at the top of the funnel and a precision tool at the bottom.

Burra further noted that the broader industry may increasingly tilt toward precision. “I believe the shift will increasingly be towards precision. Consumers today are seeking authentic, credible information from trusted brands. Legacy brands, in particular, need to move beyond just scale and focus on delivering detailed, meaningful information that enables both conversations and conversions. Ultimately, both are built on precision.”

A similar duality is visible in FMCG. Kunal Sharma, Vice President – Marketing & Organized Trade at KRBL, makers of India Gate Basmati Rice, said digital plays both roles for categories like his. From a scale standpoint, it is enabling the brand to reach more consumers than ever before. With increasingly integrated planning across brands and agencies, he noted, digital has become critical in driving large-scale reach.

“At the same time, from a precision standpoint, especially for campaigns where we want to engage a specific cohort, digital is extremely effective. It allows us to identify and target defined consumer segments with accuracy,” he said and added that therefore it’s difficult to label it as just one or the other. For brands of large scale, digital is simultaneously a scale engine and a precision engine.

This shift in advertiser mindset is also reflected in media allocations. Categories such as FMCG, auto, alcobev, BFSI and pharma are deploying digital for reach-building, brand storytelling and upper-funnel consideration. Connected TV, online video, retail media and creator-led formats are gaining share in media plans that were once dominated by performance budgets.

Agency executives indicate that while performance spends remain significant, incremental budget growth is flowing into high-impact formats. Short-form video, OTT advertising, premium publisher ecosystems and influencer marketing are seeing stronger allocations as brands seek to combine scale with data intelligence rather than rely purely on micro-targeting.

Guru Mishra, Senior VP – Media at RepIndia, said digital is no longer a siloed, precision-guided engine but a full-funnel medium operating at scale. He noted that digital now commands nearly 60% of ad spends and remains the most measurable medium, powered by AI-led targeting, programmatic capabilities and deterministic data identifying in-market audiences.

Mishra highlighted, “Digital has been built on precision and now it's expanding at much faster rate.  YT, Meta, OTT/ CTV offers more reach than traditional TV.” According to him, at the same time, he emphasised that digital retains its core performance- and attribution-led DNA. Its dual ability to drive both measurable performance and mass reach is prompting brands to explore distinct growth trajectories and unlock incremental gains across the funnel.

Senthil Kumar Hariram, Founder & Managing Director, FTA Global, described this as the central tension in the market. According to him, digital is no longer an either-or proposition but a hybrid engine delivering both scale and precision, with the emphasis shifting significantly over the past year. While it was once seen primarily as a bottom-funnel tool, the rise of Connected TV and short-form video has strengthened its ability to drive mass reach. Simultaneously, growing programmatic adoption has enabled what he termed “precision at scale”, combining automated targeting with access to large OTT and social audiences.

“Digital has firmly broken out of the performance silo. If you look at the advertising mix, FMCG, traditionally the bellwether for brand-building, now allocates 55 to 60% of its budgets to digital, up from just 30% in FY20. These are not just performance dollars; these are investments in brand equity, creator collaborations, and mass-awareness campaigns.” Hariram said. 

He added that the rapid growth of Connected TV and OTT platforms, now reaching over 40 million users, has positioned digital as a lean-back, brand-building medium. The industry’s focus, he noted, is shifting from simple “eyeballs” to Return on Attention, with metrics such as attention time and engagement redefining effectiveness. For FTA Global, the message is clear: building a brand in 2026 requires a digital-first, full-funnel strategy anchored in video and social storytelling.

Digital budget coming at cost of traditional media?

The next question, then, is whether digital’s rise is cannibalising traditional channels.

According to Hariram, while the shift may appear disruptive in the short term, structurally digital is expanding the overall advertising pie. With India’s ad market crossing the ₹1 lakh crore mark and digital accounting for nearly half of it, he noted that traditional media’s share has declined over the past five years, even as the total market continues to grow.

He described the transition as a reallocation of efficiency rather than a zero-sum shift. Digital’s superior targeting, measurability and cost efficiency are attracting new categories and incremental investments. Rather than replacing television, he said, digital is complementing it, extending reach, adding frequency and enabling always-on engagement through quick commerce and retail media, thereby unlocking new value for the ecosystem.

Mishra echoed this sentiment. “Digital growth has surely taken a leap in the last few years and it dominates the spends pie in the media mix. Despite losing share, traditional media will always remain relevant and will converge with digital to achieve marketing goals,” he said.

Taken together, industry voices suggest that India’s digital advertising market is no longer defined by a scale-versus-precision debate. Instead, it is being reshaped by how effectively brands can integrate both within a unified, full-funnel strategy.