#e4mExclusive:  MIB set to soften TV ad cap rules in relief for broadcasters

The Ministry of Information and Broadcasting (MIB) is preparing to amend the long-debated television advertising duration norms after concluding an extensive round of consultations with broadcasters, advertisers and advertising agencies, with officials now compiling stakeholder feedback into a detailed internal report before taking a final policy call, according to multiple people familiar with the matter.

The draft amendments are expected to provide the television industry with long-awaited regulatory relief, although the government is unlikely to move towards complete deregulation. Instead, officials are examining a calibrated revision of the existing advertisement cap that seeks to strike a balance between broadcaster viability and consumer interests.

"The consultation process is largely over. The ministry is now preparing a comprehensive report incorporating every stakeholder's submissions. Based on those recommendations, amendments to the advertisement duration rules are now under active consideration," a senior executive aware of the deliberations told e4m.

Read e4m report on ISA backing TV ad cap

Another person directly involved in the consultations said the ministry is reviewing not just the numerical cap but the broader relevance of the existing framework in today's media landscape.

"The television ecosystem has changed dramatically over the past two decades. Consumer behaviour, advertising economics and competition have all evolved. The ministry is assessing whether the existing framework continues to remain relevant," the person said.

Calibrated relief under consideration

According to people familiar with the discussions, the government is evaluating changes that would offer broadcasters incremental flexibility without compromising the viewing experience.

Officials said the proposal under consideration could provide broadcasters with some additional advertising inventory, though it is unlikely to amount to the complete regulatory forbearance that the industry has been seeking for years.

Read on brodcasters meeting MIB on ad cap

"The amendment is expected to provide some much-needed relief, if not complete forbearance. The government recognises the financial challenges faced by broadcasters but also wants to ensure that consumers continue to enjoy a balanced viewing experience," an industry executive briefed on the discussions said.

Another executive familiar with the policy review said the ministry is attempting to balance competing interests across the broadcasting value chain. Industry executives suggest that the government should release the draft for consultation before implementing it. 

"This is not about allowing unlimited advertising. The objective is to modernise the framework in a way that supports broadcaster monetisation while ensuring that consumers are not burdened with excessive commercial interruptions," the executive said.

Read more: Broadcasters urge MIB to rethink ad cap rule

People aware of the matter said the ministry is expected to finalise its recommendations after reviewing all stakeholder submissions before initiating the process for amending the relevant provisions under the Cable Television Networks Rules.

Industry remains divided

The ministry's consultations brought together all major industry stakeholders, but their recommendations differed significantly.

The Indian Society of Advertisers (ISA) proposed increasing the current advertisement ceiling from 20% of every clock hour to 25%, effectively allowing broadcasters to air 15 minutes of advertisements every hour. According to people aware of the discussions, ISA argued that the increase would improve broadcaster revenues without materially affecting viewers.

The Advertising Agencies Association of India (AAAI), however, advocated a market-driven framework, arguing that advertisement duration should not be regulated by the government.

According to people familiar with its submissions, AAAI told the ministry that television competes directly with digital platforms, which currently operate without any statutory limits on advertising duration, creating an uneven competitive environment.

Separately, the agency body also urged the government to restore television audience ratings at the earliest, arguing that advertisers require a credible measurement currency for media planning and investments.

Broadcasters seek complete forbearance

Broadcasters reiterated their longstanding demand for complete regulatory forbearance during the consultations.

The Indian Broadcasting and Digital Foundation (IBDF) argued that excessive advertising naturally results in audience migration, making government intervention unnecessary. According to industry executives, the foundation maintained that viewers simply switch channels when advertising exceeds acceptable levels, creating a natural market correction.

The News Broadcasters & Digital Association (NBDA) echoed the demand for forbearance while highlighting the unique economics of news broadcasting.

People present during the discussions said the association argued that news channels continuously invest in live reporting and fresh content, unlike entertainment channels that can monetise repeat programming. It also highlighted the public service role played by news broadcasters during elections, natural disasters and national emergencies.

"The industry's position has consistently been that while costs are determined by market forces, revenues continue to remain regulated. That creates a structural imbalance, particularly when digital competitors face no comparable restrictions," a senior broadcasting executive said.

Digital competition driving policy rethink

Industry executives acknowledged that the rapid expansion of digital media has fundamentally altered television broadcasting's economics.

Unlike television channels, digital platforms currently face no statutory restrictions on advertising duration despite competing for the same advertising budgets.

"The ministry understands that the competitive landscape has changed significantly. Any policy revision will have to account for these structural shifts while continuing to protect consumer interests," another person familiar with the matter said.

Industry executives said the internal report currently being prepared by the ministry will form the basis for the next stage of policy discussions.

"The government wants any amendment to be evidence-based and legally robust. It is carefully evaluating every stakeholder's recommendation before finalising the framework," another person aware of the development said.

Background

The debate over television advertising limits dates back to 2012, when the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (TRAI) capped commercial advertising on television channels at 12 minutes per clock hour, arguing that the measure was necessary to improve the consumer viewing experience.

Broadcasters challenged the regulation before the Delhi High Court, contending that advertising inventory was a commercial decision and that the regulator had exceeded its mandate.

The issue regained momentum after the Delhi High Court earlier this year upheld TRAI's authority to prescribe advertisement limits, reaffirming that the regulation served the larger public interest.

The MIB's latest review is expected to determine whether the existing framework should be recalibrated to reflect the changing dynamics of India's media and advertising ecosystem. 

Even a modest relaxation in the existing norms would mark the first significant policy shift on television advertisement duration in years and provide incremental revenue support to broadcasters navigating slowing advertising growth and increasing competition from digital platforms.