Will focus on digital privacy impact advertisers?
We asked experts on the likely implications of the recent moves by tech and social media companies towards providing users control of their digital footprint
In the online world data is crucial for businesses looking to target consumers at the right place, right time and for the right product. The digital era has helped targeted advertising become an important tool for advertisers but at the cost of being too intrusive. Thus, it is no wonder that user privacy has become a hotly debated topic. And with a good reason too.
Access to personal information based on a user’s digital footprint is mind boggling and the need for regulation, checks and balances is growing louder with every passing year. Companies like Google and Facebook often find themselves in the eye of the storm over privacy concerns.
Under pressure from regulators and the public alike, some major strides have been taken in the direction of user privacy. Tech companies and social media platforms have made some major announcements in the past few months that speak of putting control of data back into the hands of the users. Facebook rolled out the ‘Off-Facebook Activity’ feature, which gives users control over the information used by third-party apps. Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg said in his official communication: “One of our main goals for the next decade is to build much stronger privacy protections for everyone on Facebook. We know we have a lot of work to do here, which is why this is such a priority for our teams and for me personally.”
To ensure privacy for children on its platform, YouTube has announced changes to its policies in compliance with the Children’s Online Privacy Protection Act (COPPA). These new rules have been set around content marked as ‘made for kids’. Features like personalised advertising, super chat, comments, live chat or the notification bell will no longer be allowed on content made for kids.
Google has also announced its plans to end support to third-party cookies in Chrome. The goal is to make the web browsing experience more private and secure for users. However, this implementation will happen by 2022. Justin Schuh, Director, Chrome Engineering, said in a blog post: “Users are demanding greater privacy — including transparency, choice and control over how their data is used — and it’s clear the web ecosystem needs to evolve to meet these increasing demands.”
Instagram, too, plans to hide the Like feature on the platform and has been testing it globally. While this may not directly relate to data privacy, it is being done to ensure that the platform is free from superficiality in order to protect its young users. However, the ‘Like’ also has another function - in the world of influencer marketing it is a tool for brands to measure engagement or success of a campaign.
Therefore, all the browsing on the web or time spent on social media leads to mapping of preferences, likes and habits, which so far has been a gold mine for advertisers.
How will this self-regulation by tech giants themselves impact advertising?
Industry experts believe an increased emphasis on privacy will, in fact, help advertising evolve and at the same time respect consumer boundaries. Elaborating on the recent developments, Shray Choudhary, Data Protection Officer & Data Strategy Officer, Dentsu Aegis Network, said, “This basically gives out more control to the audience about their data. Targeted advertising will not be affected much by these changes. Instagram said it will not be showing likes about a post to the users anymore, even though it might continue to record them. This will still give back information to the marketer, allowing them to target a user based on this anonymised information. Facebook with the “Off-Activity Tool” is trying to make users more informed about the data they are sharing with various apps. If they wish to see all ads relevant to them, they would have the option to share or delete their data. In turn, this will help us, marketers, as well, as we will know it beforehand that the audience is interested in getting updates about a type of brand or product. YouTube Kids will start hiding comments or likes on any content if a user designates it is ‘made for kids’. However, this won’t affect targeted marketing. Most of the targeted audience is above the age of 16, which would still remain the same as YouTube says its platform is advisable to be seen by people above the age of 13 years.”
Choudhary said, in all, audience availability won’t be impacted much and the audience will be more informed. He further added that the reporting matrices for the brands will instead shift their perspective from an engagement matrix to a business matrix.
Saheb Singh - Brand Strategy & Planning, AGENCY09 said, "Whilst moves like the "Off-Activity tool" eliminate an entire audience base that simply chooses to opt-out of being targeted, this too is a boon of sorts. Instead of going for a mass, 'wherever it lands' approach, brands and advertisers can now speak to audiences who matter - and want to listen. In the long run, this will lead to better perception around ads and advertisers as well".
In India, digital advertising has been growing at a phenomenal rate. The DAN-e4m Digital Advertising Report 2020 predicts that advertising spends on digital media are expected to grow at a CAGR of 27.42 per cent and will cross the Rs 50,000 crore by the end of 2025. The report lays down that advertising spends on digital media is led by social media with the highest share of 28 per cent, contributing Rs 3,835 crore to the Indian digital advertising pie. This is followed by spends on paid search (23 per cent), online video (22 per cent) and display media (21 per cent).
Social media continues to attract most digital ad spends and experts are of the view that growth on the digital medium will not be impacted by privacy controls.
Harikrishnan Pillai, CEO and Co-founder, TheSmallBigIdea, believes self-regulation is in the best interest of the overall growth of the digital advertising ecosystem and society at large. “Look at it as catharsis in the social advertising space. And be assured that it will come back as much more effective, within the realms of respecting people’s privacy. Facebook’s off-activity tool is going to clear off digital footprint left on the platform by a confused newbie. The user will still continue to leave a footprint on the platform in some form or the other, which will be reflective of the user’s current behaviour.”
The advertising community, in fact, feels that a more controlled online space will benefit brands from a brand safety point of view.
Pillai explains that YouTube’s ‘made for kids’ is a welcome move which will eventually make it a safe destination for kids’ content and hence the advertiser. He is of the opinion that the Instagram’s Like feature over a period of time has become a mindless action and hence is not a parameter to judge content efficiency. “Pure matrices like reach, impressions, time spent, actions taken will be given more preference which would benefit the brands too at large,” he added.
TikTok is another platform which has recently opened its gates to advertisers. Last year TikTok rolled out its #BetterMeBetterInternet global campaign on Safer Internet Day. This year, it appraised its user community on best practices for data privacy and protection through various consumer-centric activities.
Talking about these initiatives, Sameer Singh, Vice President, Monetization, TikTok, said: "Safety and security of our users and brands has always been a top priority for TikTok. We employ a series of measures to provide a safe in-app environment and have undertaken several offline initiatives together with key stakeholders, including the government, industry and civil-society, towards creating a better and safer online community."
Self-regulation, says Vishal Agrahari - Media Head, BC Web Wise, is a good move and helps in building trust with the users. “Advertisers from the targeting point of view won't be impacted much as there are other options like ‘discovery content’ and similar recommended content on YouTube. The Off-Activity Tool from Facebook may or may not have made much difference to the advertisers depending on how much awareness is built around this feature. At least it empowers the users to choose if they wish to share their information or not,” Agrahari noted.
Instagram, LinkedIn, Twitter, Facebook & Youtube
OpenAI’s GPT-3 as news and SEO publisher in 2023: How to make the most of it
Guest Column: Saurabh Singh Kushwah, Digital Product Specialist, explains what makes OpenAI’s GPT-3 so lucrative
By Saurabh Singh Kushwah | Jan 30, 2023 4:52 PM | 7 min read
It's 2023 and the artificial intelligence market is scaling new heights with fiercely innovative competitors aiming to conquer the peak.
OpenAI’s GPT-3 has taken the world by storm and caught the attention of traditional technology giants Google, Microsoft, Meta and Amazon who are also vying for a piece of the AI pie with its precise, almost human-like responsive abilities.
Let’s dive a bit deeper into this emerging market to understand what makes it so lucrative:
- There is going to be an explosion in the production and usage of AI-powered devices in the next few years. This will generate a vast amount of data that needs to be processed and analysed.
- The potential applicationsAI are increasing at an exponential rate as the technology and its refinement evolves each day
- The cost of AI is dropping rapidly as the market matures and moves towards a better understanding of scaling up the adoption. This makes it more accessible to small and medium-sized businesses who can use it to enhance their operations.
- The talent pool for AI is growing immensely with increased investment in resource upskilling by both corporate as well as academic institutions.
- Most new initiatives stepping forth in the market are powered by artificial intelligence or affiliated technology. This gives rise to the need for action from the established players in the market.
These factors aided with the addictive dependence of the general population on use of technology presents a sizable opportunity for those willing to make the most of it. .
Here enters OpenAI’s GPT-3. It is a machine learning platform that helps developers work on AI models. GPT-3 has been designed to provide a high level of flexibility to developers and make it easy for them to create and deploy AI models. It is based on the open source TensorFlow platform, and is available under the Apache 2.0 licence.
OpenAI’s GPT-3 has the potential to revolutionise various industries and disciplines. And it is already being used by leading news publishing organisations in some interesting ways, a few of which are explained below:
Research - It can act as a resourceful tool for journalists covering data intensive planned events such as a state or general election. They can access specific data points such as the total participation of a particular constituency, its age and/or gender breakdown, details of the candidates etc. at their fingertips.
=GPT3()... the spreadsheet function to rule them all.— Paul Katsen (@pavtalk) July 21, 2020
Impressed with how well it pattern matches from a few examples.
The same function looked up state populations, peoples' twitter usernames and employers, and did some math. pic.twitter.com/W8FgVAov2f
Wrote something that we rewrite text using different styles. pic.twitter.com/2XRKqu3flq— Carlos E. Perez (@IntuitMachine) July 25, 2020
This eases content creation for live blog coverage with instant availability of statistical and trivial information about the background of a regularly repeated event. To illustrate an example, when a journalist is covering a live automated cricket match blog and a wicket falls, they can use GPT3 to gather relevant information about the player dismissed by the same bowler or by the same method in the past.
Demo link to generate few content using keywords.
ChatAI from OpenAI can generate news as per the available keywords given to them Generate Text
How to Approach AI-Generated Content for SEO
It is widely known that 100% AI-generated content is not currently accepted under Google’s Webmaster Guidelines. If you use GPT-3 to write the content of your website without human review, you run the risk of receiving a manual action. (You’ll probably end up posting some degree of AI gibberish as well.)
However, using GPT-3 as a tool to create your content could be a viable way to expedite your work. It could give you inspiration for your writing and help spur ideas for how to approach a topic. You could also use it to translate dense industry jargon (like translating Legal English) into something more digestible for your writing team to work from.
Even if GPT-3 delivers you coherent, relevant copy, remember that creating a truly valuable content asset is often a group effort, with subject matter experts providing information, marketing teams layering in audience pain points and insights, and design teams helping to improve the overall experience for users.
Using AI for SEO isn’t the end-all-be-all for creating valuable content. Those insights lie outside of AI’s neural network. Can it be used as a tool to get a rough draft started or expedite your research? Surely. Will it eliminate the human element from SEO altogether? Not anytime soon.
SEO Is More Than Churning Out Content
GPT-3 is an incredibly powerful tool—there’s no denying that. But if you’re looking at GPT-3 as a way to create content and fill your site with low-value content just for keyword rankings, you’ll be fighting a losing battle.
A piece published by The Verge, A college student used GPT-3 to write fake blog posts and ended up at the top of Hacker News, shows how GPT-3-generated content can pass as human-written. Passing as human-written is a long way from SEO-optimised, which is still a long way off from being valuable to users.
To drive lasting revenue, your content needs to speak to your audience and inspire additional action.
GPT-3 will almost certainly inspire SEOs to take the easy route and publish AI-generated content with little-to-no human revision. The marketers that use this tool in tandem with a thorough editing process with an audience-first approach, however, could potentially improve their ROI by expediting the first draft of their content using GPT-3 and focusing more heavily on optimising for their audience.
Keyword research and Content Strategy -
As mentioned previously, Chat GPT is a great way to quicken up lengthy processes. One SEO process that is considerably lengthy is keyword research. By using OpenAI’s chatbot, it makes keyword research similar or related keywords and ChatGPT will churn out a list of related keywords based on the AI’s understanding of the search results. Additionally, you can also request ChatGPT to determine the competition for various keywords.
ChatGPT can be a great resource for small to medium-sized companies that have little to no experience in marketing, especially SEO. You can ask ChatGPT to provide you with a content strategy for a selected business. As you can see below the plan doesn’t provide in-depth details with a plan, however, it does provide a followable plan which can help a small business to improve its marketing and SEO needs.
Generating SEO Titles on demand
One of the most difficult and time-consuming parts of SEO content writing is creating the right title to address the topic issue, feature a keyword and entice the reader to click. ChatGPT can be used as an idea generator as you can ask ChatGPT to generate titles for a topic and set the tone and the keyword you want to use and within seconds you’ll have several different titles.
After this, you can take inspiration from each recommendation and make your own title or use one of the recommendations. Within seconds you’ll have various options instead of time-consuming brainstorming.
ChatGPT has the potential to make search engine optimization readily available for businesses of all shapes and sizes with little or no marketing resources, whilst making the process faster and more efficient. It can help quicken up the topic research and keyword process.
However, there’s no guarantee that the content created by ChatGPT is original and one of a kind, with over 1 million users, the AI may recycle similar or the exact same content to different users which will negatively affect the effectiveness of using the chatbot.
Although ChatGPT is a great piece of AI, we believe you still need human touch within SEO. If you have no resources but want to improve your business resources, then ChatGPT can greatly assist you. However, we recommend contacting an SEO specialist if you’re wanting to develop an in-depth, tailored SEO strategy.
(The views expressed here are solely those of the authors and do not in any way represent the views of exchange4media.com)
Instagram, LinkedIn, Twitter, Facebook & Youtube
Will bring back Trump's FB & Instagram accounts in support of 'open debate': Meta
The tech giant also said that it has defined the criteria under which it will ban profiles of public figures after receiving critical feedback from its internal review team
By exchange4media Staff | Jan 30, 2023 1:48 PM | 2 min read
Weeks after Donald Trump's Twitter account was reinstated, Meta announced that it will bring back the former US president's Facebook and Instagram accounts in the coming weeks.
The tech giant justified its move, stating that it's lifting the two-year-old ban on President Trump's accounts to preserve "open debate" and "free flow of ideas."
"As a general rule, we don’t want to get in the way of open, public and democratic debate on Meta’s platforms — especially in the context of elections in democratic societies like the United States. The public should be able to hear what their politicians are saying — the good, the bad and the ugly — so that they can make informed choices at the ballot box. But that does not mean there are no limits to what people can say on our platform. When there is a clear risk of real-world harm — a deliberately high bar for Meta to intervene in public discourse — we act," write Nick Clegg, President, Global Affairs, Meta in a blog post.
Trump's Facebook and Instagram accounts were suspended following the January 6, 2021 violence at Capitol Hill.
Clegg explained that the decision was then referred to the Oversight Board -- a body comprising experts that performs independent checks on Meta's decision-making. The Board, while supporting the move, also criticised the tech firm's "open-ended nature of the suspension and the lack of clear criteria for when and whether suspended accounts will be restored."
The feedback prompted Meta to review the matter and then took a decision to impose a time-bound suspension of two years from the original date of suspension of Trump's accounts on January 7, 2021.
Meta also defined its criteria which could lead to the suspension of accounts of public figures during times of civil unrest and ongoing violence. It has also introduced a new Crisis Policy Protocol to guide its assessment of on and off-platform risks of imminent harm, wrote Clegg.
The executive also said that before lifting the ban on Trump's accounts, it would assess whether the risk to public safety has receded.
Trump will also be scrutinised for repeat violations with heightened penalties, said the platform.
Instagram, LinkedIn, Twitter, Facebook & Youtube
‘Monetisation of news platforms biggest challenge in digital era’
At e4m-DNPA Future of Digital Media Conference, Dr Annurag Batra, Chairman & Editor-in-Chief, Businessworld & exchange4media, spoke to CEOs on monetisation, fake news, consumer attention & much more
By exchange4media Staff | Jan 30, 2023 10:58 AM | 3 min read
At the e4m-DNPA Future of Digital Media Conference, a panel discussion with CEOs of top companies was held to discuss digital media and how the new generation of readers is influencing media houses and their ways of connecting with their audiences.
The panel was chaired by Dr Annurag Batra, Chairman & Editor-in-Chief, Businessworld & exchange4media. On the panel were Avinash Pandey, CEO, ABP Network; Puneet Jain, CEO, Hindustan Times; Hemant Jain, President and Business Head (Digital), Lokmat, and Sanjay Sindhwani, CEO, The Indian Express (digital).
Avinash Pandey spoke about the challenges in the digital era. “The biggest challenge today is reaching out to the consumer. When everybody has become a publisher and a broadcaster, how your authentic news reaches the consumer first, and how you monetize it best is the biggest challenge today in our industry.”
Speaking on the opportunities that the digital world has created for publishers, Puneet Jain said: “I think the biggest opportunity for our publishers’ communities is the tremendous interest and love we see from our users. All of us continue to track millions who are using our platforms to consume news on a daily basis. In fact, what we are seeing is a huge reinforcement towards credible journalism in these interesting times of a social world we are living in.”
Sanjay Sindhwani veered the discussion to the problem of fake news and how publishers and consumers together can fight it. “The opportunity is massive. But I think the cost is also massive. I think today what is happening is if the media business doesn't become viable, then we'll see a lot of fake news floating around. When you're trying to bait clicks, you try to provoke people with things, which may not be real or factual. So, I think that's the cost of it. And I think in a democracy, it's very important that people value good content and good news sources and learn to pay for it.”
Taking the discussion ahead, Hemant Jain spoke about how the short attention span of consumers is the biggest challenge for consumers today. “While monetization continues to be the lowest common denominator and the most common challenge for most news publishers across the world, I think if you keep the consumer at the centre of your entire ecosystem and the business model, there is a huge shift in consumer behaviour with regard to the attention span. So, if you look at human attention today it is the lowest. Now, how do you evolve yourself keeping the shift in consumer behaviour in terms of newer formats of news media content, which ensures that you are able to create the right connect with the consumer and thereby create a great value proposition is something which would which all of us would have to kind of today embrace as one of our bigger challenges.”
He ends his view by talking about first-party data as a big opportunity for media publishers and how they can monetise it. “The big opportunity I see is our investment of time, money and resource in building the first-party data because it's not just about collecting data, but it's about managing customer lifecycle. So, most of us complain about the lesser frequency of visitations in a month, lesser time spent and how do we increase frequency and time spent to increase a better value proposition for advertisers? Now, that's interesting, because we have to start thinking like B2C brands, where we start not only capturing consumer data, but also start serving content which is more relevant more contextual, and in the process, collect enriched data, which can be monetized or leveraged at a higher value or premium when it comes to advertising.”
Instagram, LinkedIn, Twitter, Facebook & Youtube
Twitter advertisers to know if ads seen by real users or bots
The platform has tied up with Integral Ad Science and DoubleVerify to ensure that the ads are seen by potential customers
By exchange4media Staff | Jan 27, 2023 11:26 AM | 1 min read
Twitter has decided to team up with ad verification companies Integral Ad Science and DoubleVerify to enusre that the ads are being seen by real people and not bots, media networks have reported.
IAS officials were quoted as saying that the move was intended at giving marketers the "confidence to continue to invest in Twitter".
In another move to lure advertisers, Twitter had said end of last year that it would soon bring new controls to allow advertisers to prevent their ads from appearing above or below tweets with certain keywords.
Meanwhile, Elon Musk recently said that Twitter higher-priced subscription models will be completely free of ads.
Instagram, LinkedIn, Twitter, Facebook & Youtube
Recognition as a separate industry & more: All that creator economy wants from Budget 2023
Well-defined guidelines and relaxations in TDS for micro-influencers are some of the other demands of the industry
By Shantanu David | Jan 27, 2023 8:32 AM | 5 min read
Aaj Tak becomes world's first news channel to cross 50 million subs on YouTube
The record-breaking milestone comes just three years after the channel crossed 10 million subscribers on the platform
By exchange4media Staff | Jan 25, 2023 9:50 PM | 2 min read
Earlier this year, Aaj Tak became the first news channel globally to cross 50 million subscribers. Ms. Kalli Purie, Vice Chairperson, India Today Group, met Mr. Gautam Anand, Managing Director of APAC - YouTube, in Singapore to commemorate the special achievement.
“Thank you so much, YouTube! This is just amazing. The team is already planning its way to 100 million so YouTube had better start designing the next button,” Ms Purie quipped to Mr Anand. “Trust has always been the foundation for audience engagement at AajTak. It’s no different with our YouTube channel, but on a much wider scale with hundreds of videos getting uploaded every day. We place equal emphasis on having new audiences discover our channel while ensuring loyal viewers revisit, and invest in figuring out what works on YouTube – whether this is a nuanced understanding of thumbnails or producing hero content frequently.”
Aaj Tak started its digital journey by launching its YouTube channel in the year 2009, and started streaming news live on YouTube for the first time in 2017. The massive popularity gained by the channel subsequently led to its Diamond play button from YouTube in 2019 for crossing 10 million subscribers. Now, just three years later, Aaj Tak is the first news channel to reach 50 million subscribers on YouTube.
“Constant experimentation with new formats like Shorts and investment into our Community page has really paid off, and consistently breaking stories has helped create a very loyal fanbase,” explained Ms. Purie. “Events like the Presidential Elections of 2022, Solar Eclipse and the Cricket World Cup just kept encouraging us to do better and better.”
YouTube has been at the forefront of India's mobile revolution, by powering the content and creator ecosystem and by propelling the massive upsurge of video streaming in the world's largest democracy. AajTak has also fast evolved its offering to meet new consumer needs, with the introduction of Shorts, and other constantly emerging insights on LIVE Streams. The channel now has a universe of committed audiences across TV, web, app and social platforms through compelling storytelling that’s tailored to individual platforms.
Instagram, LinkedIn, Twitter, Facebook & Youtube
'India will be one of the most powerful start-up ecosystems in the world'
A panel discussion at the e4m DNPA Digital Media Conference 2023 deliberated on 'Challenges before start-ups in the current digital ecosystem'
By exchange4media Staff | Jan 25, 2023 5:16 PM | 4 min read
India boasts one of the largest start-up ecosystems, enabling the dream of the country becoming a several-million-dollar economy. However, despite government measures to boost the start-ups – in terms of investments and profitability – there are challenges.
The topic of 'Challenges before Start-Ups in current digital ecosystem-Possibilities and Choices' was discussed during a session at the e4m DNPA Digital Media Conference 2023. The panel comprised Ajay Data, MD, Data Group of Industries; Murugavel Janakiraman, CEO, Bharat Matrimony; Ritesh Malik, Director, ADIF & Founder- Plaksha University; Rohan Verma, CEO and Executive Director, Map My India. The session was chaired by Ruhail Amin, Senior Editor, Businessworld & exchange4media.
Speaking about the challenges facing start-ups, Verma said, “Honestly, I think it is very clear that the entrepreneurial talent in India, especially in the digital space, is extremely high. I see no lack of capability. As we have said multiple times, the key challenge has been there because of monopolistic activities that have been suppressing the Indian digital ecosystem. That is the key challenge of our times and I'm pleased that some things are changing with regard to that.
Malik presented his observations about the challenges that have cropped up in the last few years in the start-up ecosystem: “It took 125 years for Silicon Valley to become what it is. In India, we are leap-frogging the technology era. I think we are going to be one of the most intensely powerful start-up ecosystems and technology ecosystems.
Citing the success of the UPI system in India, he added: "Our mobile payment infrastructure is way ahead of developed nations. Just think of what we will do with the entire Ayushman Bharat digital health mission. We will be one of the most technology-savvy citizen programmes in the world. So the good part is, for the first time, the government is focussing. I think we are standing on a large opportunity. Having said that, technology regulation is important. Unfortunately, it is always falling behind the actual technological innovation. In my opinion, we need to develop a special ministry whose job would be to ensure that another East India Company does not happen again and that Indians are not to be taken for a ride and that our data remains ours; that we are not just a large digital democracy for other large monopoly companies to come, use, generate revenue but also to make sure that our MSME does not get squeezed.”
Singla noted, “Even while we are sitting here, we talk about start-up and start-up ecosystem, but Amar Ujala is a hyper-local newspaper and has a presence in Tier II and Tier III cities. There, education and awareness are still required. From a media perspective, there is a good amount of innovation that is still seen as a challenge. I would say that there is a lot of room for identifying the right business sustainability model.”
Speaking on the broader challenges that need to be addressed in the start-up ecosystem, Data said, “It is extremely important that all entities work together to ensure – whether it is mentoring or education or incubation centres or investments or subsidies or government support – that the frictions between things have to be reduced. And the knowledge about the availability of those resources has to be made very simpler and easy.”
Janakiraman, who joined virtually, spoke from a sectoral standpoint and touched upon the issues that need to be overcome to render a robust start-up ecosystem. He said, “Digital start-ups can significantly contribute to country growth. Today, Indian start-ups are not only limiting themselves to country boundaries but looking at global opportunities. The Internet, 15 years ago, was free and open. Anybody could set up an Internet business or a dotcom; Internet was not controlled by any organisation. Today, the shift has happened, we all know that. The majority of the traffic is happening through mobile apps. So, more than 90 per cent of the traffic happens through the two dominant players – Google and Apple. What are the implications? Today, they are not simply platform providers or access providers; today, they are the platforms as well as players. The challenge is that when the platform becomes a player, their interest changes. Because they are commercial entities and their primary objective is to make money. And because they are both platform and player, they start abusing dominance and that is not good for Indian start-ups nor Indian consumers.”
Instagram, LinkedIn, Twitter, Facebook & Youtube