Cricket Australia faces a fresh crisis: Why Sandpapergate is a lesson in crisis management

Guest Column: Ganapathy Viswanathan, Independent Communication Consultant & Author, on reputation management lessons from the latest developments in Australian cricket

e4m by Ganapathy Viswanathan
Published: Nov 21, 2026 8:53 AM  | 4 min read
Sandpapergate Resurfaces: A New Crisis for Cricket Australia
  • e4m Twitter
  • The Sandpapergate ball-tampering scandal from 2018 has resurfaced in Australian cricket, prompted by Usman Khawaja's new book, "Sabr," which questions the handling of the incident and the team's culture.
  • Cricket Australia previously addressed the crisis with suspensions for involved players, but the renewed attention raises concerns about the institution's credibility and transparency.
  • The situation highlights that crisis management is an ongoing process; reputations can be re-evaluated years later based on new narratives or revelations.
  • Effective communication and internal transparency are crucial for institutions to rebuild trust and address underlying issues, as past controversies can resurface unexpectedly.

Crisis management is not restricted to the corporate world, brands or political organisations. It can happen anywhere, across industries and geographies. The sporting world, in particular, has witnessed several instances where a crisis has not only damaged reputations but also questioned the credibility and integrity of institutions.

The latest example comes from the world of cricket, where the infamous Sandpapergate episode of 2018 has once again returned to haunt Australian cricket.

For those who may have forgotten, the ball-tampering scandal took place during Australia's tour of South Africa. The incident involved players using sandpaper to alter the condition of the ball. Cricket Australia acted swiftly and handed out suspensions to the players involved, including Steve Smith, David Warner and Cameron Bancroft. There was considerable public outrage, and the Australian cricket establishment came under severe criticism.

At the time, it appeared that the matter had been dealt with. The players served their suspensions, the board took corrective action and Australian cricket gradually began rebuilding its image.

But was the crisis really over?

When a book reopens an old wound

Several years later, the controversy has resurfaced, and this time the trigger is Usman Khawaja's recently launched book, Sabr. His account has brought fresh attention to the events surrounding Sandpapergate, raising questions about the dressing-room culture, the handling of the incident and the way the crisis was communicated to the outside world.

What makes this development interesting is that the original incident had already been investigated and punished. Yet a fresh narrative has the potential to change public perceptions all over again.

Naresh Gupta, Chief Strategy Officer (CSO) and Managing Partner, Bang in the Middle, made an interesting observation in his post. He pointed out that it took a book to create a PR crisis of epic proportions. His comments underline how an institution can find itself defending its reputation years after it believes a controversy has been settled.

This is perhaps the most important lesson here. A crisis does not always end when the immediate action is taken. The public may move on, but the questions surrounding the incident can remain.

The communication challenge for Cricket Australia

The bigger challenge for Cricket Australia is not merely responding to the latest revelations. It is about protecting the credibility of an institution that has always projected itself as one of the strongest cricketing establishments in the world.

The questions are now much wider. Was Sandpapergate an isolated incident? Was the dressing-room culture as healthy as the establishment wanted everyone to believe? Were all the facts disclosed at the time? And how should the present leadership respond when its past is once again being questioned?

The response from the current leadership, including Pat Cummins, will be closely watched. In a situation like this, every public statement matters. A defensive response, an incomplete explanation or a lack of transparency can make matters worse.

The challenge is to communicate with honesty, acknowledge uncomfortable questions and avoid appearing as though the institution is simply trying to protect its own.

The crisis management lesson

For communication professionals, this is a particularly interesting case study. It demonstrates that crisis management is not a one-time exercise. The immediate damage may be controlled, but reputation rebuilding requires consistency, transparency and credibility over a much longer period.

There is also a lesson about internal communication. What happens inside an organisation, whether it is a corporate boardroom or a cricket dressing room, can eventually find its way into the public domain. An organisation cannot afford to ignore internal dissent or uncomfortable truths.

The concerns reportedly raised by the team's media manager at the time, who subsequently left the role, are another aspect worth examining. Sometimes, the person closest to the communication process may be the one who recognises the problem before others do.

A crisis never really disappears

The Sandpapergate episode is a reminder that reputations take years to build but can be questioned again by a single revelation. A book, an interview or a former insider speaking out can bring an old controversy back into the headlines.

For brands, corporates and institutions, the lesson is simple: crisis management should not end with a press conference, a public apology or disciplinary action. The real test is whether the organisation has addressed the underlying issues and rebuilt trust.

In the case of Australian cricket, Sabr has reopened a chapter that many thought was closed. Whether the current leadership can manage this renewed crisis without causing further damage remains to be seen.

Sometimes, the most difficult crisis to manage is not the one that has just happened, but the one you thought was behind you.

Disclaimer: The views expressed here are solely those of the author and do not in any way represent the views of exchange4media.com. 
Published On: Nov 21, 2026 8:53 AM