Marketing has never had more data. So why are the big decisions still so difficult?
Industry leaders question whether marketing organisations are evolving fast enough to turn technological sophistication into sustainable growth
by
Published: Nov 16, 2026 9:38 AM | 6 min read
- Veteran marketer Shubhranshu Singh highlights a disconnect in the marketing industry, where advanced technology and data collection fail to translate into a deep understanding of consumer behavior and meaningful business outcomes.
- The upcoming Boardroom Handbook for Modern Marketing, set to launch on December 10 in Mumbai, aims to address the challenges of aligning marketing strategies with organizational capabilities and consumer insights.
- Experts emphasize the need for collaboration across marketing, sales, and technology teams to ensure shared objectives and feedback loops, as well as the importance of integrating brand building with performance marketing for sustainable growth.
- The article underscores that while technological advancements in marketing are significant, the real challenge lies in the organizational willingness to adapt and make informed decisions based on the insights gained.
Marketing today, according to veteran marketer Shubhranshu Singh, resembles a man wearing five smartwatches who still misses his appointments.
It's a rather apt description of an industry that has spent billions acquiring the ability to know almost everything about its consumers, yet continues to struggle with some fairly fundamental questions about them.
There are more dashboards, more data points, more sophisticated attribution models and increasingly powerful AI tools promising to make sense of it all. Campaigns can be optimised in real time, creative assets generated in seconds and consumer behaviour analysed at a scale previously unimaginable. Yet the distance between knowing what happened and understanding why it happened remains considerable.
This disconnect between technological capability and business outcomes is emerging as a defining challenge for the marketing industry. It also forms the backdrop to the forthcoming Boardroom Handbook for Modern Marketing, a joint initiative by WPP Media and exchange4media, which will be unveiled on December 10 in Mumbai.
The publication arrives at a time when the question confronting marketing leaders is shifting from what technology can accomplish to whether their organisations are equipped to make meaningful use of it.
"Data tells us what consumers did. Understanding tells us WHY they did it. Growth comes from the why, yet most organisations have quietly displaced the why with the what," says Singh.
"The biggest disconnect lies between measurement and meaning. We measure everything but then make no sense of it."
Singh invokes Jorge Luis Borges' On Exactitude in Science, a short fictional work describing an empire whose cartographers become so obsessed with accuracy that they produce a map on the same scale as the territory itself. The map is eventually abandoned because its extraordinary precision has rendered it practically useless.
For marketers attempting to reconcile increasingly complex datasets, the analogy is particularly pertinent. The purpose of measurement, after all, is to inform decisions rather than merely reproduce reality in ever greater detail.
Taranjeet Singh, Chief Commercial Officer at Ecosystm, believes the industry is currently somewhere between technological adoption and genuine transformation.
"AI has undoubtedly made marketing faster, more measurable and increasingly automated," he says. "But I would question whether faster execution necessarily means better business decisions."
In his assessment, organisations are largely deploying AI to improve existing activities, from campaign optimisation to content production and reporting, without necessarily reconsidering the decisions underpinning those activities.
The distinction is consequential. A more efficient campaign may improve immediate performance, but it does not automatically improve customer lifetime value, profitability or longer-term business growth.
"Adoption is about how widely we use the technology. Transformation is about what we do differently because of it," Taranjeet Singh explains.
The problem becomes particularly evident when different functions within an organisation are pursuing different definitions of success.
Prashant Puri, Co-founder and CEO of AdLift, points to a familiar marketing paradox: a campaign generates cheaper leads and appears successful on the dashboard, while the sales team struggles to convert those leads into paying customers.
Unless revenue and lead-quality information are fed back into the marketing system, the technology continues to optimise towards an objective that may have little relationship with actual growth.
"The biggest gap is between what platforms optimize for and what the business actually needs," Puri says.
His prescription is straightforward, if operationally demanding. Marketing, sales and technology teams need shared objectives, consistent feedback loops and the authority to change course when the evidence demands it.
"The question I would ask is: what decision changed because of the technology, and did it improve the business? That's where its real value becomes clear."
For brand marketers, however, the challenge extends beyond organisational alignment to the increasingly fragmented nature of consumer behaviour itself.
Rajeev Jain, Senior Vice President, Corporate Marketing at DS Group, points out that access to behavioural data, social sentiment and AI-powered consumer intelligence has enabled considerably more granular targeting. Marketers can now identify cohorts by lifestyle, intent and consumption patterns, and tailor communication to different screens and contexts.
But the same proliferation of channels that makes precise targeting possible also complicates measurement.
"Measurement across multiple screens remains a challenge, as media is fragmented and there is no standardised tool to measure duplication across different media platforms," Jain observes.
Consumers can discover products on social media, evaluate them on marketplaces, examine them in physical stores and eventually purchase through another channel altogether. Understanding which interaction influenced the purchase is considerably harder than recording each individual interaction.
Jain also highlights the changing expectations of Gen Z consumers, who increasingly seek product demonstrations, customisation and authentic engagement rather than relying on conventional brand communication.
The implication is that better technology cannot compensate for an outdated understanding of how consumers make decisions.
That is equally true of creativity.
Vishal Prabhu, Creative Director – Strategy at White Rivers Media, argues that AI has already expanded what marketers can explore, allowing teams to research consumer behaviour, challenge assumptions and test creative possibilities before committing substantial investments.
Nevertheless, he cautions against confusing the availability of more options with the ability to select the right one.
"AI can help us explore ten different creative directions, but understanding which one is culturally relevant, strategically sound and genuinely valuable to the consumer still requires human judgement."
For Prabhu, organisations must also reconsider workflows, approval structures and the capabilities of their people. Adding AI tools to unchanged processes may deliver efficiency gains without producing a corresponding improvement in creative effectiveness.
There is another, older division that Shubhranshu Singh believes marketing leaders must confront: the persistent separation between brand building and performance marketing.
"Most companies run them as two teams with two budgets, two agencies and, frequently, two WhatsApp groups that never speak to each other," he remarks.
"Brand plants the memory that performance later harvests. Starve the orchard and every harvest shrinks.""
The argument goes to the heart of marketing accountability. Investments that generate immediately measurable responses are not necessarily the same investments that create enduring consumer preference. Nor can long-term brand building remain divorced from commercial outcomes.
Across these perspectives, a common concern emerges. The capabilities available to marketers are advancing rapidly, but the structures governing their use, from departmental incentives to investment decisions and definitions of success, are changing more slowly.
It is this larger conversation that WPP Media and exchange4media intend to bring into focus through the Boardroom Handbook for Modern Marketing, which will be launched at the e4m WPP Media Data-Tech Summit on December 10 at Taj Santacruz, Mumbai.
The initiative will bring together industry perspectives, research and India-relevant insights to examine how evolving consumer behaviour, AI, data and technology are changing the relationship between marketing investment and business growth.
Importantly, the conversation extends beyond the marketing department. Questions about customer ownership, brand equity, organisational capabilities and the effectiveness of investment increasingly demand attention at the highest levels of business leadership.
As Taranjeet Singh puts it, the biggest obstacle to sustainable growth may ultimately be organisational rather than technological.
Technology has made it possible for marketers to know more, produce more and measure more than at any previous point. Whether that translates into better businesses will depend on something rather less automated: the willingness to make different decisions.
And perhaps, occasionally, to look up from those five smartwatches.
Read more news about Marketing News, Advertising News, PR and Corporate Communication News, Digital News, People Movement News
For more updates, be socially connected with us onInstagram, LinkedIn, Twitter, Facebook, YouTube & Google News
