Top Story


Home >> Media - TV >> Article

Increasing talent hunts are cluttering Indian TV space, say experts

Font Size   16
Increasing talent hunts are cluttering Indian TV space, say experts

When it comes to programming on Indian television, it appears that what one does, others follow suit. Whether it was game shows, daily soaps or the current phenomenon of talent hunts, all channels from STAR to Sahara seem to head in the same direction. When all channels have taken such fascination to this format, the question is, ‘Is it viable to have almost five talent shows running simultaneously on Indian television?’

To get an idea of the amount of talent hunting, Sahara and Percept joined hands for Mr and Miss Bollywood. STAR India announced Indian Superstar and Zee TV’s promotion for India’s Best is already on. MTV too announced its venture with Balaji for a talent hunt for their soap. While these hunts are for actors for the big screen and small, more on the music side, Sony TV will soon come up with Pop Idols later in the year and ETC has also announced a Punjabi talent hunt.

Dwelling on the various reasons why it makes sense for channels to look at a talent show format, PRP Nair, Senior Vice President, Media Direction, RK Swami/BBDO, says: “One way to look at it is that these channels will get their own talent pool, which as you know, can be an issue of concern.”

Looking at the scene in totality, both Sahara and Zee are into movie production and while STAR has announced that it will produce a movie resulting out of this hunt, it has also made clear that another consequence would be their own talent pool for television properties.

Nair explains more on this, saying: “One definite outcome in this would be exclusivity of these stars. So you will get to see them only on a particular channel. The second thing is that it will also prove to be more cost effective to employ these people.”

“This is just another way to generate revenue. While talent hunts requires significant investments but does not require a sustained one as in the case of serials,” adds C R Mallikarjundas, Media Director, Starcom, “The commitment window is small here,” he adds.

“A talent hunt also means a very interesting TV property,” quips Sameer Nair, COO, STAR India, “We have been doing it for two years now in pop stars and we thought it is a good thing to do.”

While one agrees on all these counts, almost five talent hunts, which are similar in nature, appear to be more of a clutter rather than a clutter-breaker. In that context, can the decision prove to be an expensive one for broadcasters? “It all depends on the marketing,” expresses PRP Nair, “They have to create hype and buzz around their activities for it to be noticed at all and take the show forward from there.”

Speaking more from the advertiser’s point of view, Mallikarjundas remarks: “These properties would be good only in terms of sponsorship. That is where the value for money will lie when it comes to advertisers. In terms of spot buys, I would still rather put my money on serials that would give me adequate TRPs.”

Are the channels worried? Satish Menon, President, Marketing and Sales, Sahara Manoranjan responds: “We have no reasons to be worried. We are already done with round one and well on our way to the next. We have stolen a march over the others and if there is a reason for anyone to be concerned, it is not us.”

“Since everyone is hunting in a similar manner, we will have to do it differently,” states Sameer Nair. “The scenario is indeed cluttered up and we will have to do something about it,” he adds. Just to look at the current status, Sahara’s Mr… is already finished with its first round, while Zee’s India’s best has begun with on-air promotions. STAR on the other hand has not taken the activity further at all.


Vijay Mansukhani, speaks to exchange4media about the resurgence of Onida, the scope of growth of consumer electronics market in India and the reasons why Indian consumer electronics brands don’t compete on a global scale

Projjol Banerjea opens up about hiring Anne Macdonald and GroupM's Rob Norman, and the brand's new identity

Meera Iyer tells exchange4media that in FY 2016/17, bigbasket clocked a revenue of Rs 1,400 crore. The online supermarket currently stands at 70,000 orders a day, with operations in 25 cities.

CMO, Kashyap Vadapalli on the start-up’s marketing play, why it has decided to stay away from IPL and response to its furniture rental apps

In terms of affiliates, India ranks on the top. Spurred by the fast growth of mobile users and hence internet users, there are millions of websites, apps, WAP-sites and blogs using affiliate marketing...

Insecurity in the workplace due to the idea of AI encroaching on your job, or being sidelined at work because of your small town background? Sandeep Goyal has the right answers to help you deal with w...

As National Sales Head at, Ashish aims to bring on board a maximum number of advertising partners and consolidate the network’s position as a leader in the space.