Home >> Media–Print >> Article

Edit Page: Gone with the winds of change?

07-February-2011
Font Size   16
Edit Page: Gone with the winds of change?

The announcement by Daily News & Analysis, better known as DNA, that it would no longer have an edit page took many by surprise, and left several industrywallahs shocked. IMPACT magazine felt it warranted discussion, and organised a roundtable on the issue at the Press Club in Mumbai, on February 3, 2011.

Aspects of the edit page – from its importance, its readers’ connect and its marketing value to the changes that it could go through, were tackled in the well-rounded discussion. The panelists who participated were Aditya Sinha, Editor-in-Chief, DNA; Aroon Tikekar, veteran Editor and historian; Bharat Kapadia, Director, Lokmat Newspapers; Ajay Kakar, Chief Marketing Officer – Financial Services, Aditya Birla Group; columnist Ranjona Banerji; and Divya Radhakrishnan, President, TME.

Aditya Sinha confessed that when he had first joined DNA, he found that the paper lacked a distinct identity, and this made him think. As the paper itself includes “analysis” in the name, he said, it called for more of it, and the paper’s new move only takes that to the micro level by having comment and opinion on different relevant pages instead of clustered together on a single page, which he felt was a mechanical approach and ended up being a limitation.

Sinha also said that the stature of writers needed to be taken into account. In the light of damaged credibility, journalists needed to take a step back, get off their high horse and give space to expert comment, he added. “If journos themselves don’t respect sanctity, how can we talk about the sanctity of the edit page?,” Sinha asked.

Aroon Tikekar, while remarking that DNA and Sinha should be congratulated for its bold and revolutionary move, also strongly pointed out that the editor was the “face” of the paper and was bound to take a stand as he or she served an important social function. The editorial and the edit page, even if read by a minuscule percentage of readers, had sanctity, he insisted, “because those are the people who count”. He further said that there were three important aspects to a newspaper and added that newspapers unnecessarily competed with television channels, when instead they needed to be vehicles of social change.

Bharat Kapadia pointed out the “pathetic” condition of the edit page in some language newspapers, wherein the edit is not written by the editor himself, but outsourced. “It is like a sixth finger,” he said, which was there, but didn’t know what role it played. He observed that most popular newspapers had not seen change in years, thus losing the relevance of the edit page with the availability of opinions everywhere else.

Bringing a marketing perspective to the issue, Ajay Kakkar explained that since the edit page did not have a rate card to it, its pull value could not be gauged. He remarked, “The king is dead, long live the king,” and observed that we were emotionally attached to the editorial page, when in reality one might not have missed its absence if it had not been announced. “In this new world of speed, we will have the editorial as a point of view in different spaces,” he said, adding, “but if the editorial point of view dies out, then yes – the newspaper will die.”

Before satellite television, a media buyer was considered smart to buy the front page, the back page and the op-ed, which was then charged at a premium, said Divya Radhakrishnan, especially in newspapers which had a strong edit. She further said, “If you want to follow standpoint, today every editor is on Twitter”, and one didn’t have to wait for their opinions in their respective papers the following day.

Ranjona Banerji said that when the edit page was introduced in Mid-Day, the paper had gained credibility and weight, and readers began taking it more seriously. The edit page told readers where to go to find comment and opinion, she said and remarked that the edit might not be relevant to people every day, “but there are times when that voice is vital”.

Journalist Naresh Fernandes, who was in the audience, remarked that the edit page gave room for honing the craft of writing, and some of the best reading could be found on the editorial and opinion pages of the world’s newspapers.

Also contributing their points of view via email were Mid-Day’s Tariq Ansari and veteran journalist and editor Sidharth Bhatia.

Tariq Ansari said, “The editorial page is an important device so that newspapers can signal clearly to their readers the difference between news and views. At a time when the line between the two is being blurred, if a newspaper dispenses with its editorial page, the temptation to editorialise in the news columns needs to be resisted through an alternate device such as Times View, which is a clearly flagged opinion space.”

Sidharth Bhatia stated, “News and information can now come to you in an instant on a variety of media, ranging from television and radio to handheld devices. But there is growing consensus that readers will demand cogent and well-thought-out analysis on issues. A newspaper’s stand on these issues helps clarify people’s opinions and distinguishes one paper from the other.”

He also remarked, “Not every issue is an earth-shattering one which demands front page edits. Often a local subject needs commenting upon. An edit page serves that purpose.” However, carrying analysis scattered along with news could confuse the reader, he said.

Although no consensus as such was reached at the discussion, which was moderated by exchange4media Group Chief Editor Pradyuman Maheshwari, it was agreed that the move by DNA and its Editor had been a bold and brave experiment. Aroon Tikekar quipped that DNA might well see the return of its edit page, while Aditya Sinha said that a newspaper had to evolve to keep up with rapid changes, and there were factors that forced it to evolve.

Whether the absence of a demarcated edit page will make a difference is for DNA’s readers to say. Until then, the debate continues.

Also read:
DNA drops its edit page; scribes react sharply

 

Tags

Varun Raina, Marketing Manager, Airbnb India speaks to exchange4media about the successful #LiveThere campaign and how Bollywood helps them connect with its young consumer

Tim Castree is all praises for his team in India and trusts it to be a result of “an excellent execution of agency’s global strategy” headed by Kartik Sharma

Siddharth Dabhade says Criteo’s technology allows brands to engage with shoppers, create relevant experience on retail apps, thereby driving sales and profits

Shantanu Gangane says OTT platform Viu plans around 20+ originals and is all set to enter the Tamil market with a mix of syndicated and original content

right
left
OFF THE CUFF HAS JOURNALIST ARUN SHOURIE IN CONVERSATION WITH SHEKHAR GUPTA IN MUMBAI IAA HOSTS FIRST INDIAA REGIONAL AWARDS (TELUGU) IN HYDERABAD BREAK THE CEILING TOUCH THE SKY 2018 SEES OVERWHELMING INDUSTRY PARTICIPATION 10TH EDITION OF ABC EUREKA AWARDS IN MUMBAI CELEBRATES WORK OF PARTNER AGENCIES EMINENT JURY PICKS LOUDEST’S 100 MOST POWERFUL INDIAN MUSIC BUSINESS LEADERS MODE LOFT BY SABGROUP LAUNCHES SIGNATURE MENSWEAR POWER DRESSING CLOTHING LINE TOP MARKETERS DISCUSS ART AND SCIENCE OF EFFECTIVE LISTENING @PITCH CMO SUMMIT 2018, DELHI THIRD SEASON OF ‘INDIA’S TOP DIGITAL PLANNERS’ RECOGNIZES EXCELLENCE IN THE DIGITAL INDUSTRY WOMEN ECONOMIC FORUM 2018 SEES DISTINGUISHED GLOBAL PERSONALITIES IN ATTENDANCE PEPPER CREATIVE AWARDS 2018 RECOGNIZE THE BEST IN ADVERTISING IN SOUTH INDIA RADIO CITY’S POWER OF RADIO MEET HOSTS TOP ADVERTISING INDUSTRY LEADERS TOP INDUSTRY PERSONALITIES ATTEND ZOOM-MYNTRA EVENING TO CELEBRATE THEIR PARTNERSHIP LEADING MARKETERS, EXPERTS SHARE INSIGHTS ON DIGITAL TRANSFORMATION @ADOBE SYMPOSIUM IN MUMBAI NICKELODEON TRADE PARTY SEES MARKETING INDUSTRY LEADERS AND THEIR FAMILIES IN ATTENDANCE GOLDEN MIKES RADIO ADVERTISING AWARDS 2018 RECOGNIZE INDUSTRY’S MOST DESERVING ACHIEVERS AIMA MANAGING INDIA AWARDS HONOUR THE BEST IN THE INDUSTRY BW BUSINESSWORLD’S GREAT INDIA DEBATE BRINGS TOGETHER INTELLECTUALS ACROSS INDUSTRY SECTORS BW BUSINESSWORLD SMART CITIES CONCLAVE PATNA 2018 SEES EMINENT INDUSTRY LEADERS IN ATTENDANCE EMINENT JURY PICKS WINNERS OF GOLDEN MIKES RADIO ADVERTISING AWARDS MADDYS 2018 SEE TOP ADVERTISING AND MARKETING INDUSTRY LEADERS IN ATTENDANCE

He spent 13 years at HT; his previous stints include Whirlpool, Procter & Gamble and Godrej

The case study explains in detail the people strategy executed at GroupM to ensure its talent is digitally charged and is data-centric.

As Zee Telugu completes 13 years, Anuradha Gudur tells us about the channel’s journey