Home >> Media-Others >> Article

Mixed Media: Why MIB must junk some of the Amit Mitra committee’s recommendations on ratings

12-January-2011
Font Size   16
Mixed Media:  Why MIB must junk some of the Amit Mitra committee’s recommendations on ratings

If the Government were to accept all of the recommendations made by a committee it set to review television audience measurement tools, it could well be time for TAM Media CEO LV Krishnan to take some hard decisions on his 13-year-old research firm. For, the Ministry of Information and Broadcasting-constituted committee has clearly indicated that TAM can’t be involved in the ratings business since it is part-owned by advertising conglomerate WPP. TAM incidentally was set up at the behest of a joint industry body in 1998.

One would’ve assumed that committee chair Dr Amit Mitra, who, as Secretary General of the Federation of Indian Chambers of Commerce and Industry (FICCI), has been running the annual Frames jamboree for many years, would have a good idea of the way the business of media is conducted. For, suggesting cross-ownership restrictions in media is as bizarre as saying that the government mustn’t run two transport corporations by way of the Indian Railways and Air India. Or closer home, The Times of India mustn’t be allowed to run Times Now or Radio Mirchi or an outdoor company or an events and activations outfit. Or a STAR India can’t have stakes in Tata Sky, Star Den and Hathaway.

But then, Mitra and Co had a task to do. Under pressure from all and sundry, the Government instituted a committee in May last year to determine a response to the cries that the current measurement tools are ineffective and that Government intervention must regulate them.

The unfortunate thing about Mitra’s task was that the very premise on which he was asked to submit his findings was flawed. For one, TRP is a measurement currency that is deployed by advertisers (directly or via its media buying agency). The advertiser in question doesn’t owe any explanation to the government or even the public for advertising in or sponsoring a certain programme. It could be a sound reason like a show’s popularity or just a whim. There is no way large spenders like Hindustan Unilever or Nestle or Micromax can be policed on their spends. They will do it the way they want.

Thankfully for all of us, buying decisions are generally not irrational. Though in the case of niche products (like print magazines, for instance), where prevailing measurement techniques don’t work, ad sales are indeed influenced by perception.
There is a discussion on how TRPs compromise content quality and how making the announcement of ratings less frequent could help. In fact, this is echoed by many broadcasters. My view is that the suggestion is outlandish because the advertiser has every right to know how its money is doing. And since our channel owners do not all have a magic potion on content, there is fair reason for aggressive monitoring.

Ratings are said to be the cause for influencing broadcasters to tweak serial storylines and news channels to sensationalise. There can never be more hogwash than this. Yes, news channels do opt for popular fare because that’s the kind of stuff that draws viewers. But that’s the nature of the beast. We all know that there is a fair amount of top quality content on Doordarshan, Lok Sabha TV and the like… how many of us watch them? Ratings are just an indicator of what people like to watch. And I don’t think the effect will be any different if the viewership numbers are shared once a fortnight, month or quarter.

Yes, there just 8,000-odd Peoplemeters from TAM and that number ought to increase. But will 30,000 Peoplemeters, as the committee says, be enough? I am sure that the same argument of whether the 30,000 number is truly representative of a billion-plus populace will be used then too.

But of course not all of what the Dr Amit Mitra committee has said is trash. For instance, the assertion that self-regulation (and hence not government-initiated) of TRPs is the best way to move forward is welcome. The committee has also said that the industry needs to move its feet on the setting up of BARC (Broadcast Audience Research Council). I like that Mitra has said that BARC must reorganise its Board and set up the high powered committee by June 2011 or face government intervention. There are also valid points raised about the need for all stakeholders to pay more for audience measurement if they are seeking an enhanced sample. The committee has recommended that the government reduce the 50 per cent import duty on Peoplemeters and has asked BARC to consider indigenous manufacture of measurement boxes.

I am a little concerned about the issue of transparency and the integrity of the data available. Surely, no research agency will want to part with the info on the people who have the boxes at home. While it’s true that broadcasters try their damnedest to indentify the homes with the boxes, I don’t think it’s all that simple. Also, from what I remember the TAM folk telling me, their intelligence network is strong enough, and if there is any issue on integrity, the sample is done away with in double quick time.

I am a little unsure on aMap’s ownership, and its officebearers weren’t the most cooperative with the information, so I don’t know if at all it will be affected by the crossholdings rule.

One hopes that there will some voice of reason at the MIB headquarters in Shastri Bhavan and some of the suggestions will be reviewed. If the Government is serious about quality audience measurement tools, then leaving it to the industry’s brainstrust would be the ideal solution.

(The views expressed here are my own. Post your comments below or mail pradyumanm@exchange4media.com. Twitter: @pmahesh)

 

Tags

Varun Raina, Marketing Manager, Airbnb India speaks to exchange4media about the successful #LiveThere campaign and how Bollywood helps them connect with its young consumer

Tim Castree is all praises for his team in India and trusts it to be a result of “an excellent execution of agency’s global strategy” headed by Kartik Sharma

Siddharth Dabhade says Criteo’s technology allows brands to engage with shoppers, create relevant experience on retail apps, thereby driving sales and profits

Shantanu Gangane says OTT platform Viu plans around 20+ originals and is all set to enter the Tamil market with a mix of syndicated and original content

right
left
OFF THE CUFF HAS JOURNALIST ARUN SHOURIE IN CONVERSATION WITH SHEKHAR GUPTA IN MUMBAI IAA HOSTS FIRST INDIAA REGIONAL AWARDS (TELUGU) IN HYDERABAD BREAK THE CEILING TOUCH THE SKY 2018 SEES OVERWHELMING INDUSTRY PARTICIPATION 10TH EDITION OF ABC EUREKA AWARDS IN MUMBAI CELEBRATES WORK OF PARTNER AGENCIES EMINENT JURY PICKS LOUDEST’S 100 MOST POWERFUL INDIAN MUSIC BUSINESS LEADERS MODE LOFT BY SABGROUP LAUNCHES SIGNATURE MENSWEAR POWER DRESSING CLOTHING LINE TOP MARKETERS DISCUSS ART AND SCIENCE OF EFFECTIVE LISTENING @PITCH CMO SUMMIT 2018, DELHI THIRD SEASON OF ‘INDIA’S TOP DIGITAL PLANNERS’ RECOGNIZES EXCELLENCE IN THE DIGITAL INDUSTRY WOMEN ECONOMIC FORUM 2018 SEES DISTINGUISHED GLOBAL PERSONALITIES IN ATTENDANCE PEPPER CREATIVE AWARDS 2018 RECOGNIZE THE BEST IN ADVERTISING IN SOUTH INDIA RADIO CITY’S POWER OF RADIO MEET HOSTS TOP ADVERTISING INDUSTRY LEADERS TOP INDUSTRY PERSONALITIES ATTEND ZOOM-MYNTRA EVENING TO CELEBRATE THEIR PARTNERSHIP LEADING MARKETERS, EXPERTS SHARE INSIGHTS ON DIGITAL TRANSFORMATION @ADOBE SYMPOSIUM IN MUMBAI NICKELODEON TRADE PARTY SEES MARKETING INDUSTRY LEADERS AND THEIR FAMILIES IN ATTENDANCE GOLDEN MIKES RADIO ADVERTISING AWARDS 2018 RECOGNIZE INDUSTRY’S MOST DESERVING ACHIEVERS AIMA MANAGING INDIA AWARDS HONOUR THE BEST IN THE INDUSTRY BW BUSINESSWORLD’S GREAT INDIA DEBATE BRINGS TOGETHER INTELLECTUALS ACROSS INDUSTRY SECTORS BW BUSINESSWORLD SMART CITIES CONCLAVE PATNA 2018 SEES EMINENT INDUSTRY LEADERS IN ATTENDANCE EMINENT JURY PICKS WINNERS OF GOLDEN MIKES RADIO ADVERTISING AWARDS MADDYS 2018 SEE TOP ADVERTISING AND MARKETING INDUSTRY LEADERS IN ATTENDANCE

He spent 13 years at HT; his previous stints include Whirlpool, Procter & Gamble and Godrej

The case study explains in detail the people strategy executed at GroupM to ensure its talent is digitally charged and is data-centric.

As Zee Telugu completes 13 years, Anuradha Gudur tells us about the channel’s journey