Top Story

e4m_logo.png

Home >> Marketing >> Article

IPRCCA 2016: Panel dissects issues plaguing media in the age of mistrust

16-December-2016
Font Size   16
IPRCCA 2016: Panel dissects issues plaguing media in the age of mistrust

The seventh edition of Indian Public Relations & Corporate Communications Awards (IPRCCA 2016) witnessed an intellectually stimulating panel discussion moderated by Kumar Deep Banerjee, Head –  External Communications, Vodafone India. In the words of Banerjee, the discussion on “Media in the age of mistrust” brought together an “eclectic mix of ladies and gentlemen”.  

He initiated the discussion by referring to the words of Denzel Washington who spoke of being “uninformed” if one did not subscribe to the media but “misinformed” in the case one did.

Mistrust & Credibility

Describing the current situation as “alarming” and “crucial”, Pooja Pathak, Co-Founder & Director at Media Mantra felt that there were no bullet point solutions to the same. Emphasizing the need for integrity, she stated that mistrust wasn’t solely a concern for the media.

“The issue of mistrust is across sectors,” Pathak said as she cited the current tussle between Ratan Tata and Cyrus Mistry as an example of corporate mistrust. In the case of the recent surgical strikes in PoK, she suggested that the mistrust had assumed an exaggerated level since certain people had started doubted the narrative of their nation’s army.

On the other hand, Sharif Rangnekar, Chairman, Integral PR, argued that mistrust is not “good for business” though “it might be good” for a few media houses who mislead people. He was clear that credibility was an issue which was more or less to be sorted by the media.

“The problem resides mostly with the press that is owned by corporates,” he said. While PR agencies represented their clients, he added that the Chinese wall that was meant to insulate a newsroom from outside pressures wasn’t functioning well.

Manipulation & Sensationalism

The two non-PR professionals on the panel did not hold back their opinions during the panel discussion which was later on opened to questions from the floor. Addressing the “realities of the times we live in”, CNN News 18’s Bhupendra Chaubey conceded that “some of the best stories” he has done recently came from the “PR industry”.

He frankly admitted that press and PR can “co-exist” and “cooperate”. “I have no problem with a PR person coming and telling me about a story as long as it is factual,” he added. For Chaubey, a cause for worry was the manipulation of social media as he had witnessed the doctoring of Twitter trends. Citing examples of his television shows, he narrated how politically impactful journalism often fails to satisfy the beast called TRPs which recorded an “abysmal” showing.

“Seven times I let my heart decide, three times I let the realities of the times decide,” he concluded as he spoke of opportunities even in these testing times. Filmmaker Vibha Bakshi also brought to the fore some instances from her professional journey to emphasise on the significance of restraint.

“You have to be very responsible as a documentary filmmaker,” she said. While working on her film ‘Daughters of Mother India’, Bakshi noted that she had access to the “Delhi Police command and control room” and could have got “sensational quotes”.

However, she chose not to do so. “We have seen how people sensationalize and get more eyebrows,” she stated while elaborating on how India’s image had been tarnished globally due to sensational documentary filmmaking. She took the opportunity to thank a PR firm without whose support her film ‘Daughters of Mother India’ could not have seen the light of the day.

Moderator Banerjee wrapped up by the discussion by reminding everyone that showbiz necessitated the need to “glamorize facts to an extent” but ethics and core values could not be compromised upon.

Tags

Vijay Mansukhani, speaks to exchange4media about the resurgence of Onida, the scope of growth of consumer electronics market in India and the reasons why Indian consumer electronics brands don’t compete on a global scale

Projjol Banerjea opens up about hiring Anne Macdonald and GroupM's Rob Norman, and the brand's new identity

Meera Iyer tells exchange4media that in FY 2016/17, bigbasket clocked a revenue of Rs 1,400 crore. The online supermarket currently stands at 70,000 orders a day, with operations in 25 cities.

CMO, Kashyap Vadapalli on the start-up’s marketing play, why it has decided to stay away from IPL and response to its furniture rental apps

In terms of affiliates, India ranks on the top. Spurred by the fast growth of mobile users and hence internet users, there are millions of websites, apps, WAP-sites and blogs using affiliate marketing...

Insecurity in the workplace due to the idea of AI encroaching on your job, or being sidelined at work because of your small town background? Sandeep Goyal has the right answers to help you deal with w...

As National Sales Head at News18.com, Ashish aims to bring on board a maximum number of advertising partners and consolidate the network’s position as a leader in the space.