Top Story


Home >> Media - TV >> Article

After recusal of judges, TRAI-Star dispute likely to go back to square one in Madras HC

Font Size   16
After recusal of judges, TRAI-Star dispute likely to go back to square one in Madras HC

The legal proceedings in the tariff order dispute between Star India and Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (TRAI) are all set to go back to square one, after the recusal of judges hearing the matter in the Madras High Court. While Star India and the central government had completed their submissions before the court, TRAI was in the process of making its submissions through its counsel, P Wilson.

The next step in the proceedings was the intervention of All India Digital Cable Federation (AIDCF) following which Star would have been given the opportunity to counter-argue. However, the new bench, which will now be appointed by the Chief Justice to look into the matter, will begin to hear the arguments from the concerned parties all over again. As a result, Star India and AIDCF will have to make their submissions once more.

In early March, while permitting TRAI to notify its tariff order, the Supreme Court had directed the Madras HC to dispose the case within a period of 60 days. The two-judge bench had already spent more than 30 days adjudicating the matter. Justice Indira Banerjee, who was sworn in as the Chief Justice of the Madras HC on April 5, is expected to nominate a new bench to preside over the case by Friday.

The resolution of the dispute will depend greatly on the pace and urgency exhibited by the new bench in settling the matter. It is Star India and Vijay TV’s contention that TRAI has violated the Copyright Act and overstepped its jurisdiction by pricing content through its tariff order. TRAI, on the other hand, has maintained that it is well within its powers to regulate the broadcasting sector and the pricing. With the publication of the tariff order in the Gazette of India on April 3, TRAI’s ruling is slated to come into force on May 2.

Earlier this week, an “anonymous petition”, described as a “ghost letter” by our sources, led to the voluntary recusal of Justice S Nagamuthu and Justice Anita Sumanth from the case. The petition alleged that Star India’s counsel and former finance minister P Chidambaram was approached by Justice Nagamuthu to be appointed as a judge. As the proceedings lay scuttled, for now, a source, speaking on the condition of anonymity, claimed that the damning objections could not have come from the side of Star since no petitioner would downgrade its own counsel.

The recusal of the judges came as a “huge surprise” to all those who were closely following what has been a long-drawn battle between broadcasters and the regulatory body. In October last year, TRAI came out with the first draft of the Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable) Services (Eighth) (Addressable Systems) Tariff Order, 2017. The order outlined the seven genres, which each channel had to identify itself with, besides prescribing genre-wise price caps. After receiving a nod from the Supreme Court in March, TRAI notified the tariff order but handed out some concessions to broadcasters, which included doing away with genre-wise price ceilings. 

Kranti Gada joined the family business at Shemaroo in 2006 after a successful stint of over two years in marketing at Pepsi Co. She has been associated with the company for 12 years.

Exchange4media interacted with Jaspreet Chandok, Vice President and Head (Fashion) , IMG Reliance Pvt. Ltd on seamless brands integrations planned for Lakme Fashion Week, walking tall despite blazing trails like GST, demonetization and being a part of the larger cultural space

Their strategy to educate the consumers to make well informed decisions at all stages has worked out well.

Bobby Pawar, MD, CCO - South Asia, Publicis India, talks about his idea of chilling out

V-Guard Industries, a household name for consumer electrical appliances in India, has revamped its logo in order to reflect the strength gained by the brand over the years. The company has also unveil...

The report reveals that there has been nearly 5 times more growth in video consumption in the last 12 months, with 96 percent of all usage being focused on long form video

Gopalan currently leads the Indonesia operations of P&G, and will be taking over from April 1st, 2018 as Al Rajwani is set to retire after 37 years with the company.