Top Story


Home >> Media – Print >> Article

Media coverage of Bhopal encounter better than Ishrat Jahan case: Siddharth Varadarajan

Font Size   16
Media coverage of Bhopal encounter better than Ishrat Jahan case: Siddharth Varadarajan

The day after Diwali began on a strange note in Bhopal when eight alleged terrorists belonging to the Students Islamic Movement of India (SIMI) broke out of the high-security central jail in the city.  The men in question also killed a head constable. Media reports claimed that three of these were repeat offenders who had earlier tried to break out of another jail three years ago in 2013.

Hours later the eight men were killed in an encounter by the Anti-Terrorism Squad. However, some videos that surfaced from the site of the encounter raised serious concerns regarding the authenticity of the entire operation. India Today TV aired one such video that was clearly labelled as “unverified”.

On the other hand, a section of the news media was quick to label the deceased as “terrorists” despite the men being under-trial. Headlines of various news reports published on several websites including The Times of India and Zee News identified the accused as “terrorists”.

Terming media’s usage of such terminology as unfortunate, Siddharth Varadarajan argued that the media often treated accused persons as guilty. “An under-trial or a man accused of terrorism will almost invariably be called a terrorist in media narrative or media reporting particularly once they have been killed because there is nobody who will come back and sue you. I think this is one of the careless and unethical aspects of the Indian media,” said Varadarajan, Founding Editor of The Wire.

The former editor of The Hindu held the overall coverage of the encounter to be quite good as some television channels helped question the police’s theory on the basis of certain videos. “I would say the media coverage of this has been fair to the extent to which the media has allowed questions to be asked of the police version. It is something which normally has not been happening,” he added.

Varadarajan felt that the media had acted very differently in the encounter case of Ishrat Jahan through its “motivated” and “shameless” coverage. He stated that “large sections of the media have been party to the government’s attempt to cover up the killing of Ishrat Jahan” by indulging in irrelevant detailing concerning the first and second affidavit.

“In this particular case, the media has done well by asking the right questions. Of course, the labels it has attached are all wrong,” he said.


Naidu also talks about the ushering in of a new era of digital payments and says this is just the beginning and there’s lots of space for newer players to step in and evolve

The production house has already established itself as the leader in the non-scripted genres. However, Rege now wants Endemol to achieve the same in the original scripted zone and film production

Markus Noder, Managing Partner, Serviceplan International, shared innovative tools, ideas and methodologies to generate tangible business values

The primary reason that led to growth of OTT is the constant improvement of internet speed and service across the country: Sandeep Gupta, ACT Fibernet

Prominent newspapers in Manipur left their editorial space blank to protest the burning down of copies of a local daily reportedly by BJYM, the youth wing of BJP

At the recently held India Public Relations & Corporate Communications Awards 2017 (IPRCCA), communication experts deliberated on various aspects of the industry and searched for best practices that c...

A few years ago, YouTube’s Robert Kyncl anticipated that by 2020, 90 per cent of all internet traffic will be video and it appears that his prediction is turning into a reality