Top Story

e4m_logo.png

Home >> Media – Print >> Article

Anil Dhirubhai Ambani Group’s BSES Limited seeks Rs 5,000 crore in damages from BCCL

09-September-2015
Font Size   16
Share
Anil Dhirubhai Ambani Group’s BSES Limited seeks Rs 5,000 crore in damages from BCCL

BSES Limited, a company in the Anil Dhirubhai Ambani Group (ADAG), has sought Rs 5,000 crore as damages from Bennett, Coleman and Company Limited (BCCL), publishers of the Times of India, for allegedly defamatory articles printed by the newspaper in August 2015. (source: The Hoot)

On August 18, the TOI carried a series of articles by Josy Joseph based on a draft report of the Comptroller and Auditor General of India (CAG) that found various discrepancies in the accounts maintained by electricity distribution companies in Delhi.  The same day Mulla & Mulla and Craigie Blunt & Caroe, a firm of lawyers acting on behalf of BSES Rajdhani Power Limited and BSES Yamuna Power Limited (both part of BSES Ltd of the ADAG), served a notice of defamation on BCCL.

In their legal notice, BSES Limited are claiming that the stories ‘Delhi discoms inflated dues by Rs 8,000cr: CAG’, ‘Delhi govt representatives in discoms slammed’, ‘Discom audit: CAG points out conflict of interests in deals’ and ‘Discoms made money from meters, says CAG’ carried “False, fictitious and unacceptably offending claims, statements and inferences and conclusions” and the reporting was said to be “actuated by malice and per se defamatory”.

It also mentions that the access to the draft report is subjudice since an interim order dated January 24, 2014 passed by the Delhi High Court had stated that the final report of the CAG on the subject would not be submitted without the permission of the court.

The legal notice has been served on Bennett, Coleman and Co. Ltd., the owners of the ToI, Balraj Arora,  publisher of the TOI, Arindam Sengupta, Executive Editor, TOI, and Josy Joseph, correspondent, TOI (He recently joined The Hindu).

In response to the legal notice, BCCL has pointed out that “In the said news reports, we have not taken unilateral views and have published your clients’ position qua the CAG report. We have specifically stated that “The companies have, however, denied the report and claimed that it is both incomplete and subjudice.”

In another instance, BCCL’s response goes on to say, “The report from a constitutional authority that enjoys the highest credibility not just in India but all over the world should be treated with deserving respect. The CAG is not India’s government auditor, but is also a member of the UN board of auditors. The CAG’s authority, competence and autonomy should and cannot be called to question for private interests.”

The reply adds, “There has not been any injunction, restriction or direction by any court of law on the publication of any article on the Delhi power distributor companies and imposing such a ban would be threatening the freedom of press and an assault on democracy. It is not legitimate to claim a right to privacy and confidentiality on the part of the distributor companies when larger public interest is involved. The articles carried by ToI are not personal opinions or allegations but reports based on information received by reliable sources.”

Chitresh Sinha, CEO, Chlorophyll Innovation Lab and Vivek Singh, Joint MD, Procam International speak exclusively with exchange4media on the upcoming #BeBetter Campaign for the TATA Mumbai Marathon

Abhishek Punia, Co-founder and COO of ARM Worldwide, tells about how they re-branded themselves from ARM Digital to ARM Worldwide and in the process marked their presence globally

Srinivasan opens up on what prompted their recent rebrand, their foray into bus depots and developing the software that displays Bengaluru Metropolitan Transport Corporation's (BMTC) Passenger Information System for all the major bus depots in Bangalore.

Software and Technology, Consulting, Healthcare seem to be increasingly using Webinars to engage with their clients and employees

Latestly focuses on all latest and breaking events across the globe, providing information on trend related stories across genres

As part of this re-imagined approach Star India will broadcast live matches in six different languages with an aim to target 700 million viewers across TV and Digital.

Rahul Johri, CEO, Board of Control for Cricket in India (BCCI), spoke about the upcoming season of IPL and with Star India’s re-imagine approach, he made assured that this year will be a kickass seas...