Press plan for North India? OK.
TOI & HT for Delhi. Tribune and Punjab Kesari for HPC. Jagran and Ujala for UP. Bhaskar and xyz for …. !
The plan is quickly churned out by equating a geographical region with two or three leading newspaper titles. And as these big newspaper titles guzzle the press budget, there is little left for magazines, especially 'niche magazines'.
But why should you and your client bother about Magazines? Simply because, NRS data reveals that magazine readers, and niche magazine's in particular, have the highest affluence levels! Given the drive to improve ROI of media investments, they make worthy candidates for your press plans.
Before we build a case for magazines, lets look at the macro picture. A look at the Chart 1 will show that magazines are indeed low on priority. Only about 16% of all press spends goes into magazines advertising.
Chart 1: Magazines have only 16% share of Press Budget (Rs Cr)
But how much can magazines contribute to generating sales and market share? One obvious way is to look at how many readers they have, against dailies. But are you chasing readers or are you interested in a 'market'? Guess, the second one. Therefore, to benchmark the true worth of what print titles individually and collectively can contribute; we computed the total Readership Net worth by multiplying Key Durable Ownership with the approximate MRP of durables. See details in 'Methodology' below.
The results are an eye opener. Amongst top 50 publications (newspapers and magazines) sorted by total Net Worth, magazines have 80% share! In other words, if the collective net worth of all readers (duplication included) is Rs. 100, magazine readers have a worth of Rs. 80. Only 9 dailies figure in our top 50 list. Click here for the list.
Lets look at some data used for our conclusion. Table 1 shows the traditional 15-list basis the readership. Newspapers dominate this list completely. Only 3 magazines feature in this list. But when we compute the total Readership Net worth, we see a surge in magazine titles. See Table 2. Of the 15 titles, 8 are magazines! This simple analysis shows that while Newspapers may have more readers, it is magazines that have better profile.
| Table
1: Top 15 by Readership |
| |
|
Readership
('000') |
| Hindi
Dlys |
Dainik
Bhaskar |
11943 |
| Hindi
Dlys |
Dainik
Jagran |
11417 |
| Hindi
Mags |
Saras
Salil |
10696 |
| Mal.
Dlys |
Mal
Manorama - D |
9785 |
| Tamil
Dlys |
Dly
Thanthi |
9731 |
| Telugu
Dlys |
Eenadu |
9067 |
| Mal.
Dlys |
Mtbhmi-M |
7337 |
| Marathi
Dlys |
Lokmat |
7320 |
| Hindi
Mags |
Grihshobha |
6748 |
| Hindi
Dlys |
Amar
Ujala |
6514 |
| Bengali
Dlys |
A.B.P |
6135 |
| English
Mags |
India
Today - Eng |
5761 |
| Hindi
Dlys |
Hindustan |
5756 |
| Hindi
Dlys |
Nav
Bharat |
5630 |
| Hindi
Dlys |
Punjab
Kesari |
5534 |
| Source:
NRS 2001 |
|
| Table
2: Top 15 by Total Net Worth* |
| |
|
Durable Totals
(Rs 000) |
| English Dlys |
Times of India |
646983 |
| English Mags |
India Today
- E |
630688.5 |
| English Mags |
Readers' Digest |
516986 |
| Hindi Mags |
Grihshobha |
484682.5 |
| Hindi Dlys |
Dainik Bhaskar |
448153 |
| English Mags |
Filmfare |
436931.5 |
| Hindi Dlys |
Dainik Jagran |
433080.5 |
| English Dlys |
Hindustan
Times |
383351 |
| Hindi Mags |
India Today
- H |
310515.5 |
| English Mags |
Stardust |
309137 |
| Hindi Dlys |
Punjab Kesri |
306782.5 |
| Mal. Dlys |
Mal Manorama
- D |
287296 |
| Gujarati Dlys |
Gujarat Samachar |
250917.5 |
| English Mags |
Femina |
248744 |
| English Mags |
CSR |
245113.5 |
| *
Net Worth is calculated by cum value of key durables owned by readers |
5939362 |
| See
Methodology for more details |
|
Before we move any further, a quick primer on what we really mean by 'total Readership Net worth'. For each print title covered by NRS 01, we generated the Key Durable ownership. Key Durables were essentially 7 high-ticket items like Colour TV, Washing Machine, PC etc. We then allocated a MRP value to each durable and arrived at the 'total Readership Net worth' by addition the product of each durable ownership and MRP, for each title separately.
While these are Top 15 titles that have large readership bases, how about the niche magazines? Do they deliver significant value? Yes, They Do.
When we calculate Net worth per reader, we see some amazing outputs. All top 15 titles, accept two, are magazines and all of them are niche magazines! Special interest magazines Cosmopolitan, BS Motoring, GladRags find themselves in the top 10.
See Table 3 below.
| Table
3: Top 15 by highest Net Worth per Reader |
|
|
Net Worth
('000) |
| English Mags |
Teens Today |
217.52353 |
| English Mags |
A&M |
214.35185 |
| English Mags |
Cosmopolitan |
205.42308 |
| English Dlys |
Financial
Express |
201.03333 |
| English Mags |
GladRags |
189.75313 |
| English Mags |
BS Motoring |
177.8494 |
| English Mags |
Auto India |
176.68997 |
| English Mags |
Savvy |
176.47135 |
| English Mags |
Car&Bike |
175.3869 |
| English Mags |
Inside Outside |
171.58424 |
| English Mags |
NewsWeek |
171.25658 |
| English
Mags |
FortInd |
168.28788 |
| English Dlys |
Tribune |
166.40225 |
| English Mags |
Intelligent
Investor |
161.7089 |
| English Mags |
PCQuest |
159.25 |
| Source:
NRS 01 |
What can be the reason of this dramatic difference in newspaper and magazine readership and product ownership?
Clearly, niche magazines have a better readership profile (as measured by Key Durable ownership). Assuming that cost- per-contact of niche magazines is close to mass titles, they offer a strong rationale for inclusion in press plans. Perhaps, at the cost of a few insertions in colossal daily titles.
Methodology-------------
To calculate 'total Readership Net worth' we calculated the following:
Step 1: We assimilated total readership (U+R) and product ownership of each print title covered by NRS.
Step 2: We allocated approximate MRP for each of the seven products (Col TV, Motor Cycle, Scooter, Cars, AC, Washing Machine and PC, and multiplied the same with product ownership of each title. We then cumulated Net worth of individual products to arrive at 'total Readership Net worth' for each title.
Step 3: To calculate Net worth per reader for each title, we simply divided the 'total Readership Net worth' by total readers.
|