Top Story


Home >> Goafest2011 >> Article

GoaFest 2011: Auditor’s experience in Creative Abby

Font Size   16
GoaFest 2011:  Auditor’s experience in Creative Abby

Following the fiasco of last two-three years, Creative Abby 2011 witnessed one of the toughest judging processes to ensure fair play and a good awards show. In the big scene, orchestrated by Awards Governing Council (AGC) Chairperson, Shashi Sinha, who is also CEO, Lodestar UM, auditor KPMG had a very key role to play.

Right from the round one of judging, KPMG was checking and cross-checking that entries sent were genuine and credited accurately. In the process, a clear message had gone out to the industry that the AGC was not shy in employing any means required to clean up Creative Abby.

Speaking on the auditor’s experience, in a conversation with exchange4media, Shashank B Karnad, Executive Director-Advisory Forensic Services, KPMG, divulged the whole process and the client feedback that KPMG received.

One part of the key process was creating forms that did not allow any self-voting. Karnad said, “We had a simple excel spreadsheet that blocked all entries of the jury member’s agency, for him. It just kept things simple.”

On connecting with the clients, he said, “We had all kinds of experiences with the clients in the course of verifying the authenticity of entries. We had some cases, where clients confirmed that the work was done for them by that agency, and we included that work in the awards. But we also had cases where clients pointed out that the work was not done on their behalf and then we did what was required. The point here is that this process has worked well. We gave it ability to go back to clients, and hence allow a fair process on the whole.”

In some cases KPMG officials went and checked with the clients, in other cases, they sent an email for the work that was done with the jpeg image of the exact work that was winning the award. Karnad explained that in round one, KPMG could not do this for everybody as there were numerous entries, so a random pick of clients was done. He added, “This spread the message that KPMG was doing checks, and in fact, we had begun to see some withdrawals at the first stage itself.”

As is known, at the Creative Abby this year, several entries were withdrawn at various stages.



Speaking with exchange4media, Rishi Darda, Joint Managing Director and Editorial, Lokmat Media Group shared his vision for regional publications and the impact of IRS 2017 on the print industry.

Nisha Narayan, COO & Director, RED FM & Redtro and CEO, Digital Radio (Mumbai) Broadcasting Ltd, shares her insights on how radio is a powerful medium in terms of advertising and what can be done to take it to the next level

The popular channel from the Viacom18 ‘s umbrella MTV Indies, which aired music by independent artistes, was replaced by MTV Beats, a 24x7 Hindi music channel in 2016

Bhasin on the checks and balances of new IRS, methodology with new companies like Vedsur on board, interpreting the data and why it’s not fair to compare with previous data

The popular channel from the Viacom18 ‘s umbrella MTV Indies, which aired music by independent artistes, was replaced by MTV Beats, a 24x7 Hindi music channel in 2016

Backed by four properties including the first test match between South Africa and India of Freedom Cup, Sony Ten 1 continued to lead Top 5 channels in 2018’s second week (January 6-12)

Vijay Shekhar Sharma stated that this is the right time to create an Indian model which would be the envy of the world